A B C DEFGHIJ∗ < = !!>"?#"$#%@&*'K(L)M*N+O,.-P$Q% (9V)*KLUM .(^9_V6WX)*KLMXY13`a[b]U (9V)^_6X7RZ/07cdefW)7RYZ1/X07*1207cRghiX7jkl.^_6mT./K7n4o = R ! "#@*1L2M34 (LM O 5
Cournot .PQ=STU (9V
N * (9V9d:R Z ` a*KLM. (LM[ . R ZZ *KLM. f *(KLLM*1=U (9V T!"*12347cRf% )* M T(R9 V(9V#$d *KLM*1= *KLM&' [().*1239:=`)*KLMX7TR (9Vd)*+,-*+,-$%m*1239:m/07c∗Ki
L M Nj OPQRSTU{|SVWXYZTU{|S¬kl®m¯noKpLg°q±rstuvwxyzr£¤¥¦§
¨yza©ªb«c dNSeC K L f g Hh ST{VÀÁÂXYqaa²³´µ¶·¸¹ºR{|V»¼½XY¹¾¿XYZPQRØÙÚÛËÜbKLfÝÃÄxÅÆÇÈÉÊËÌÍÉÊÎÏaÐÑÒÓÔÕÖ×
{ |Þ . /0N0O123456789:3:;<=>?@ABCD4EFGHIJKLM4004H4685?9]@A^BPQRSTU2VWXUYZ[\klm_M4NO`=?@ABabWHBcYdCefghi9jl;nopqjrWnoast
uHv cYoswt Kindxucyin^g z{H|}~9\`=?@ABHO3_67\LKR4?@CWHKj ¡¢D4`M4FGaHlabH©vLª|}C£¤a_¥HIJ\¦§IJ¨M4?@ABPQe0q0uitAyB«¬;K|a®~HIJ¯jk4H°\µ^¶·=4¸`¹?@A Bcontrols ºH exNpoOrt aWYsh±»are² lorceaqluciHroenmteenntts] ºK³´Blm¸H¹I l=ocKalceilings \¦¿ÀÁÂÃ
]4ÄKpLrotecti¦on ºu¼H½Å¾ importÆj°´ÇÈ44ÉHGCÊË4HefÌÍHKi=V0H0|ÑdÒHJÅ\H=¯R¸®¹~AB°44HÎÓÏ==E?¸¹\ClmIл=ÕÖ×H¸¹ØÙÚÂ@ABNOHÉ=ÔKkÓM4NOHÞ¹z{lÛÜÝ\Ã
]4Ä=¸¹×H çK·ßà¸á`âãäGHM4NO»å{æ¼ðKñ`=O?@èA Béêk]ò4òëì3Ró`k=¾OôKíÃîï opendoor policies çè
éêõÉö÷Cøùß·=¸¹ºB¸¹kÿ =ú=¸¹ûüÂýþäG½çè éêl67 K·
2¸ ¹` 34 ô = O = l¾ôlL k ½ K4 æ
Híl
267C_ ï! l"#KC$4%` l u=¸¹00v&^'_\oHYw=+ ¸£¹¤,æKH()4Y`w= EÁNÂODaav-idsÜonHe=tal ¸ ¹
K.*/|0kqr4n
HefÌÍ\ðRßodàriákâ ã
ä å 1æçkèlémênëoìíHîYæwç+ï ð;2®~ lIJK 3 ,×æK``=>?4@HAeBfa^49H:=H¸¹\Liu± k
5 {®=~ENO_67L8óH¹`?@ABH=EFGRºv°4;a-ÜH=¸®~Rd=4>½H <\ChaoandYu
00ChaoandYu R?GH@ABK=¸¹Hefgh\~í
l|ÃC´®~íÎÏ=¸¹ïHDEKj F®¸Î¹Ïï»=H¸¹ÑdÒHJ|\}3\G*
|HkRlImtnÃoJs(t)YKwL=BK¸ ¹CBj°M4FGHMrû=4M4FGNqOôç;HÎÏ Ñdl9H=B¸¹°PéK 0
0
|lH|ÅzHSQTR¸1¹^®\B~U!V\4Wl;KHCÎhÏao=and¸Y¹u
K RaCChaoandYu°lmnoYwK|1YZkqrnoYwH+X3®~HYw+X°Hymer
\Kindleberg§[HÒJ\¦jHaK Rer
(,æ]M4FGDjz^N_`BABHIz^N_`HbcdeBkqrnoHYw+X3®~=>?@äjKJRûñCh°aofa nd\YWug K
ÂlI|klmjn44`H=IEFGahiHóopHm×ðKYZ²«qñ°lmãrs¥K |R´úYwHuVv]R=¸¹CItÞ5Hd9\W!K°B¸¹Kkysz´YwuVVHwx½K| z®~004|{;4°=´EFyG=HE?F@GA`BN|O \b}W <`~=»E\FRG {4=BK0¸¹0|\
]4ÄÀ{s4Daº®~FHsëGH]6K4 zu¼*GH\¦jÂÃ4AB
Àj]47ÇÈKbW67\= {4^*GHbc~»KuLS67q4?@ABKÜ0l0^| 4D4ÜN´OlC=H=EuEN¼NOûO_Õt`8H4\bcHÕstê ñlmã4BkqrnoHYw+ 3uvYw\ÕstK Rz^N_`bcH{4
0 0|{Ü4;{|Þ lj`=`=ENOaIH°×Kr±²^òt]é\ENOHÖ×IKlj`=ENOÉ4bcH×Içès0t0K~|9Hde4·HBÎ]Ï=6°¸ÿ¹\Wg6]4Ü´l=ENOÕ4bcH4bc4C=ECpêW!61ñlmã~9 4bc4C=ENNOOÕÕBBKK44;HSÎÏ=I¸¹=êW¸ ¹6~9RÎÏ pCÎÏ=¸¹\W6°|Hd9\BH ¡¢£¤0 é0\R =6E]NKO{H44³´¥Rl4G]K=¦K^ÿÂ3?4@A;BaH4=HE=NO¸Õç貸ú¹°æ¼å34\§=ENOHÖ×°4; ô=ENO¹K=Q±fqKH×°αKα¨Â C ÐVK =ENOH=×°fαqKR4bcH°e ectiveprodfP[( −α)qu]c\ef( −α)qr\Rp{¯ric4Üe4Hof5=gboocd¸ H¹©ª=«Ü°∗PK4bcH¬~»®°αBHK4=E5N©OªaC4É©ªH^Tgó©°ª±n th]e¹∗αP+(H Y−αw)Pj^çè´µ éK\$§G={ENOH²5W«Ü°fc\°´³=¸H²¸5¹W.4f∗c>Pçè é\°¶=ENOR4ºQfc=IÂ4=HK² 5·Yw=∗PK¸1¹=EN¯O?zTü´µ4;3 ô=K00R4;H+:K|{44;±²`=EN\l°×K§p°tçè éê»lOH^g]4;`=ENOaIH°=¸¹K=¸¹°α\=ENOa^×±²^òzSH@A]ljzYɺ=L`0;0¼½k½HÐ4×ÜKIê6gHjst`ÞÉ°l4Éb¾c¿HHÀ×ÁI\W\l¾¿]K4Ü-ÿÜÂÃ×HðKp=tEN=OԸܹαÎêÏWHg¾×¿\°×Ôܾ¿KR4;ô
00°´³a®~Hßàá´âãÄäñå°æÅçÆèéKêë6ìúíYîæÇçïð S<°ÉHÎÏÑd]@A l °Rp®=~RÈlÜòH@A<B°K=~4;HÎÏ=¸¹ê@A g ÉÊR9;ÎÏpHÔ=¸¹=ÈÜH@ABK4×LK4;Üê±@A`= !E N°OI4É;SÔÜÎÏpC=¸¹\¹00°»«ÀÁÐíËÀÁ^Nnoï subgaCme`perafec^teq×I\úüÍÎ»Ì KDÌæWg¾¿HnoðK ÏWluil¾ibr¿ium» ÌK»ÌSH4;0Î0ÏRWg\¾¿]K=ENOлfÑHÎë\fÑ®±ÉÊ°f∗ffffpi=[αP+( −α)P]q−cq−t( −αγ)q ½X]Kγ±²° p \γ= ÉÊ0ê4;`=ENOHa^×nI×0γ==E NÉOÊÒÓ4×;kÔ`ë=ãEfNÑOHHlɾ"Õ×°I\f∂pif∗ ′ffpi==αP+( −α)P+( −α)Pq−c−t( −αγ)= çè
é
ff∂q{Ö\4fÑÔëãHg¾"Õ f ff ′′′fpi=∂pi/∂q=
( −α)P+( −α)Pq< Wff`0=0EN
O XH×lH¾"Õ°N×YK±«4;a-ÜH×tC=¸¹αfpifftq=−tf −αγ=
( ′−α)P+( < ′′f−α)Pqpifff∗pifαfq=−=−αf
′f f{P−[P+( −α)Pq]}−{( −α)q[
′P+( ′′f−α)Pq]+tγ} ′′′f( −α)P+( −α)Pqpifffd( −α)qff=( −α)q−qαdα
{|Þ ( −α)∗′=−[P−P−( f−α)qP+tγ]< çè é fpiff×005 { \X É ÊXÉpÊHÊÊÚÚ=bW¸=¹E`N=OEHWÊÚK ³«=ENOHHYÜ°Ý fÑÔëNO×H zØÙ\ XÚÛ±kHg¾"Õ K XH9ÝÔÂYË\YËH9ÝOØÙáâ+=:3¸Þ¹Ø\ ÜDLKú=¸É¹HHÜ×ßãàL´=NOHYdK =ENå45bc½a8óH²5·å45bcKÂ∗PIÂR4Ébc5{a5{H²5·P¦+(g hÉH′f−α)PqRK g Xhγګ²=YEËNHOW^lëkä5åq3YÏKû ô=abWH¾ô\$G±ú ghæ°∗f{P−[P+( ′−α)Pq]}\w±ç=¸¹`Â=ENO×Hí?@ghïK½ÂY4bcèHå²°5Ý\·»Kl¦+:Kg=hE1N³O«RNO4^b8có××H5{.ÊÚR 9² KY$ËGHæW g°=ëä¸å¹qYaÊKHK· XÎÚ−={E( NOf−α)q×[
H′P+íV( @′′f−α)Pq]+tγ}KÝ°CVé\@RgjhH+ éXw±¬K =¸¹ÊÚ`=ENO×gHhï\ Âz?Ù@Ügçèh00RçK=¸¹HÊÚ.³«=ENOR4H×5{\ÂW^l¾4¿N]KOK4 e;fRÔ®ëã44êH.ìeífTHîÅïëB-;ÜHÎÏ·ðW\] fffW={U[( −α)q]−P( −α)q}+t( −αγ)q½HX]K·\W$lGñHDë`äeåfÉÊ®ìNí×TYîkï+K¯WBg|ÃH1Y°w]4;`=ENOaI′fff′fdW=Ud[( −α)q]−Pd[( −α)q]−( −α)qPd[( −α)q]f+td[( f−αγ)q]+( −αγ)qdtffff=−( ′−α)Pqd[( −α)q]+td[( −αγ)q]+( −αγ)qdtçè
é
00kB$GúYÇß®à~áÿâã|äaåÊæçHèé!êòë@ìAíBîæHçï4ð;ÎÏ\ 0000@ Añ l± Y]Ç4;R×=H@ABK-ÜÎÏ=¸¹\ 4;`=E~N9OH;Ö`×=IENOIÉC`Ö×Iò@ò\(γ= )K X±ßó°dW=−( −±«f′ffα)qPd[( −α)q]+tdq\ú½X`=¸¹α×Y ú
XHl¾"Õ o∂W∗fff ′=[αP+( −α)P−c]q+( −α)(q)P α∂α400;½jXõHûè-åÜ lz9ÙHÜ\=$G¸±¹\R =¸¹°PH@A;2ô<½Xk~9α= K½X±ßó°∣∂W∣ff′f P−c)q+P(q) ∣α∂αα= =(0i0 ½ÙXÜåÚ+HWgðÝêWlÃHèå1CfqwSK ½XHèå α ÎÏ\H¶==¸¸¹¹°HP\Ê Ú.³=ENOH×5{f(q< )K1½X°ÝKαK1ÎÏ=¸¹±²°9K=¦É¸Ê¹ HÊöÚ÷.=³=ENOH×8óf(q> )α4bc½H×5{K¸¹HÊÚ.³=ENORï ìíTîïHø?KR·H8óëSìíTî00H ø?±«K4 ;4`=;EùNûO-HÜÉl9H×=I¸¹\(γ= )Kúef®`α×Yf∂Wd( −α)qf′=[t−( −α)qP]<
∂αdα=½X]¸K¹]HäÊåÚlØÃ÷°9Krfd[( −α)q]/dα< Kak½XHèå°ÝK¦ÉÊ ¶4;`=.E/N0OI4ÉefÌKÍ1Kzû K ÎÏH=¸¹û°PK;¯÷`=ENOIÉK·h ô=K= EôNO=Ø÷\.¦5j{R°44H
e×K· z./04Hì{|íÞTî ï K µ . ³·5{K· ú 40f0H/k0½\H~9$G±k«qBÂHúJ\ 1û ü=ý 0¸ ¹=HEÊNÚO.³Õ=E4NbOcHK׶8ó4K;Î`Ï==EN¸O¹HÖ×IK4;`=ENOIÉK1zû ô=ENO=\±²°9ê¶0000ú@A gX `]p4;R=t×Y±«¸4¹e=fÔHë@HAlB¾K"-ÕÜ°ÎÏHp\∂Wf ff′=( −αγ)q+[( −αγ)t−( −α)qP]q= t∂t00{4efÔëãHg¾"Õþÿ\ X±Ì«fqt= f′[( −α)P−pi] ff−αγR~|»{ 4 ~z»j nottooconvex H@ABK XHèå°9çè é\pOH\Öl¾ ×" IX zj çè éK X±ç 4;`=EN±ß(γó=° )KÂ`=ENOIÉ(γ= )HÕK±Ì«i94;`ft( −αγ)=q[(= E−αN )OHÖf′P−pi]×KúI½XHdh o
XffENOH×nwSçè ép`ÉIK=`É\ i94;`=ENOHÖ×IpBÂúJI\KÎÏpBHÖ·(t( f−αγ)q)QwS\k½Hdh±k«qû û*ü` = 0ERN«OÜIH=\¸4¹B;K`¦4bcH~» zj K14;HÎÏp°0KRgT³=ENNOqHÖ×I×wSHKÎ Ïp;sH`ÉI i94;j`=ENOHÖÖ·QwS\ÌÍnwS\×Ip`É×IK4Hef
00@A ! ]4ßà;áâSãä-åÜæÎçèÏéêpëCìí=îæ¸çïð ×0Y0± «DK 4;`=ENOIɹ\(γ= )Kú XYÇ`αCt∂Wd( f−α)qf=[−( ′−α)Pq+t]<
∂αdαf∂Wd( −α)q′ff=[−( −α)Pq+t]+( −α)q= ∂tdt°00
X±çÎÏH=¸¹°P\úα= o X±Ì«ÎÏpK4f′;zÙf ô−= t=−q[P−(dq/dt)]\EN½OÂ=dh±çKê R~4» ; z`.= E NHO@IAÉBÙ`=ENOIɱ³«4Hê.efK;`=ENOIÉ qÎë\¦j 4ú.§=ENO5{R4KH¶ ×ôK=ELN³O=4ìH K1C@A l l K 4efH/0K íTîï·n5{K 00 K 4;`Î=ÏE=NO¸¹°P\CHÖ×I(γ= )Kú XYÇ`αt×Y±« XC∂Wf′=−( fd( −α)qff−α)qP+tq+q= t∂tdt°090K¦ j X°±=çK¸ ¹H4ÊÚ;^`±=²E³N«O=HEÖNO×HIÖK×Î8Ïó=Ð \¸ ¹±Î²Ï l pHC ÎtÏd=h±¸¹HÔÜû C X
Ö»Ì\@A g C@A00k½HYwKç$KG ±kΫÏq=B¸ú¹JC\ÎÏp^±²S°9\ NûOüI É 0RK41Î;ÏS=-¸Ü¹°pPC=¸¹H@ABK¶4;`=EÎÏ=¸¹±²°9\RòI+êX¶BK4ÎÏ;`p=nEûN°O9H\Ö×IK1
ú0 J0
Âl={E4NKOñlÕmã4~¥9l{|ÞGH @ A z ÀÁK RBl6]K$G_` H@A\4Q^NO>R lG C=ENO ¢ ¡ 00R\½Rl66]K]K$$GG~ 9u´l= EôN~O½lÕ6H4dbhcRB HÕÎHÏb=cd¸e¹BCI÷WÖ\ KR6]K$G J
=Ejõùbc]³´^lNOÕ4bcH{4\{44®×_`\{4=4ENNOO¦ÐR=K4»É^l4NOS CÐ Cournot=KR4;H=¸¹»BK K±L²==ENO1³´R4É0«0§4NOH×°5W«Ü°çè é\hhqK²c\ù§=4bcH©ª=]Ü°∗fhPK § 4bcH¬~»®°P(Q)KQ=( −α)q+qKR=Q°¸=¹ENOC4NOR4bc½HÖ×Kf( −α)q1°=ENO00 =K°α´H³¾ôB´ÉÄñ°4ÅbÆcKH×\~9=¸¹6 Dz~94;HpL@A\\RBl6]$Gul ~94;SòH=0E0NO6HH=st¸ù¹jlêW¾g¿¾H¿À°Áb\cR_ `À¾Á¿HKWl¾¿K4;-Ü`ôBC4NOR4bc=ENOR=¸¹H¾00RWg¾¿]½uvCournot®×_`\®YÇ°K=ENOC4NOÔÜ×kÔëã ºHfÑKfÑf∗fffpi=[αP+( −α)P]q−cq hhhhpi=Pq−cq 00ÄNOÔëãfÑHl¾"ÕYÇ°
ßàáâãäåæçèéêëìíîæçïð
f∗f′fpi=αP+( −α)P+( −α)qP−c= fhh′hpi=P+qP−c= h{4fÑÔëãHg¾"Õf ′fpi=( −α)[
P+( ′′−α)Pq]< Khpi=
′P+ffhhnhW′′qPÖ<\ {C4KLÄ NÜOHH"_Õ`° f fhstrahtegicsubstitute′ K′′∆=pipi−pipi=( −α)P( ′P+PQ)> ffhhfhhffpi=( −fh00′ú C ′ ′ fα)[P+( XHlh¾"Õ′h′′−α)Pq]< Kpi=( −α)(P+qP)< \hfdh]N×Y úl¾"Õ o±«kB¸s H ff∗hfq=(c−P)pi+α [q]
fd( hh−α∆−α)q fff∗h=( −α)q−q=(c−P)pi<
αhhdα∆h−pihfhf∗q=(c−α∆( P)>
−α)0ÜK0R Ø
÷C.³
= EXNÉOÊÉ=¸4¹bHcÊHÚ®`×=5E{N\O
Ö X×ÉHÊKR+é z Ù00h(piR<W )hflH¾{¿4]BKK=4¸;¹-HÜÊlÚÎ.ϳH«=4NO×8ó\ Â^·K 4H f®ì¸í¹Tîïkл4ê fÎë\W]HfÑaðhW=[U(Q)−PQ]+pi
00ú½XHef®`α×Y±«=¸¹`4efH°fdWd( −α)q′′h′hhh′=UQ−PQ−QPQ+(P+qP−c)q+qPααααdαdαd( f−α)q′fh=P[−( −α)q−Qq]
αdα
0 0úWg¾¿]ÌæH¸s {|dÞh o ½ X K 1½X±ßó°′ dW(P)fhh ′′P∗f=[( −α)q−q−(q)](P−c)
′dα∆PýX]K∗fP−c< K dW/dαH9Ý fhh ′′′[( −α)q−q−(q)P/P]lÆ0a0Ô~$Ü9G\±
D {X4\ 4H~»®° linear ç′′P= éKk¯²ñÅNOR44bcH~»®° K$G±k!½=E4ê.ebfcH½H\ =×ECNO4RNO4b×cH½wH`ëI×3ë'Â"=4N¸O¹H×`¬Ð =fEh(( −α)q−q> )K
X±çdW/dα< K =¸¹û*:I:#êKNOR4bc½H×IÂ4NOH×fh(( −α)q−q< )dW/dα> KÉÊ=¸¹û*:ë:O00R ~4»H °× Ú Â convex ç#\′′P> éK¶( fh−α)q>qK¶=EN³«4Hê.ef/0\4¬NÐOKH¶=×EKN1OdWR/dα4<H KÉ×ÊI Â=¸¹8ó.×K1 =¸¹8óKR~» z. H4NOHÚ@ABK4HefÌÍ.Ê0\0»=K ~» °$ ±¸Ç¹%concave ç′′P< éK¶h( f−α)q<qK1HdWÊ/Údα.>³ «KÉ4ÊH e=fEÌNÍOR4H×IÂ4NOH×K= N OHH@A×ÊÚ\÷L =ENOR4H×ëÂB((K =¸f¹Hh−α)q>qÊ)Ú³W«/dα4HHèeåfz̲ÙÜKRjR~» 00qÅÿ°&K$Gµl~9ÎÏH=¸¹\ö÷Í/0\NOR4H×ëÂIÂ4NO$Gy(ç'YÇR=EH+éKR· z×BK=¸¹àQ`4efÌÍ~93YÿkÔÜÎÏH=¸¹\kB`W(α) H¦0~09° ´w zÎ~³Ï»®HH(=@Hò)¸\*¹SÂ+\,Kr°´ñ ªH()´µKkB$Gú
0NKO0±H çlÎ×Ã-;ß^à áôâ=ãEäåNæOç=èéêëìíîæçïð (α= )K¶=ENOH×IÂ4Ï=f¸h(q<q¹)Kû1°9 \
§ X±4«(;dW`/=dαE)|aNOa²′- ÜfHÎhë=∗f)(q−q)(P−c)/= =(P¸¹∆°>αK =¸¹°αK=ENOH×CfÑú.1ÂPçè ¸¹.1Âé\ =αK
X±«′ h∗(dW/dα)|=−(P)q(P−cα=αe~9±ç08®çè éK ±ú=f¸)/¹∆> \½W(α)ûjl/ªαC4 fÎWÏH_|1·2 \2 ±çÎÏ=¸¹Ø°3Ì cornersolution K00 lHÃ=-¸;¹û^° ôαK=ÉEÊNO;û4±² ô=ENOú=\4ÂNOH×=(α= )K¶=ENOH×ëÂ
fX±h(q>q«)K
X±«(dW/dα)| =¸¹α.1αKα= < KL(dW/dα)|> \ α=αs|±ÉÊ·2
K ±çÎÏH=¸¹ûjP=p¸¹αC4efWH_αH3Ì\° $GØÙ¸»00W°(α´=ñ Å)CÆWÞ(αØ=Îα)ÏÐ=ëI¸\¹H()´µK$ 4½ìÂíeTfîgïhC\ {44N4OÉfHѬa~e»WH®e°G kª®H+X3fP®=°a−bQ\¼½
XK W(α)= {[
( ∗f−b( −α) h α)a+αP−c−( −α)c]+
∗f[( −α)a−αP+c−
( h−α)c]}
00ú½X`α×Y±«5 67fh(q<q)|α= 89:;<=>?@ABCDE
{|Þ 5 6 7fh(q>q)|Eα= 89:;<=>?@ABCDdW=dα
{b( [( −α)MM+
( −α)NN]+(M+
N)}
αα−α)ú½X
] K∗fh∗fhM=
( −α)a+αP−c−( −α)c,N=( −α)a−αP+c−
( −α)c\ X`α×Y±«dW =dα
{
(M+
N)+[M+( −α)M]+
[N+( −α)N]}>
ααb( −α)½X%Ø´W(α)°l ®K ÎÏ=¸¹û°
;HÎÏ°^Nz ô=C4±² PpαH3ÌK400 ô=gTÐl\α= K=ENOC4NOH×YÇ°h(a−
fc+c)/ bC(a−hfc+c)/ bK
XH4H fW° fha−c−cW=W(α= ()= hf)(a−
c+c+b
)
b×0°0 =¸¹°αKhQ=qK 4Ébc4NOÕK4NOHhhq=(a−c)/
bKb c©ª°hP=(a+c)/
K 4H fÌÍ° h(a−cW=W(α=α)= )
b
00ú
C
ßgàXáwâ5ãä±å«æçèéêëìíîæçïð −(a−
fhc+c)[W−W=
h(a−c)+
fh(c−c)] ½X]Kbha−c> Ka−
fhc+c> çè
é\ ½XHèåÔÜ
OÉ K²5Ê WH w`ëI\ =ENOH²5W4NOH²5ÂWÄNfhcÚÂcW−W< K ÎÏH=¸¹é\R=ENOH×û.°IÂ4NOH×Khα\`ûÂÿ|H~9Kfc>cQfhα= H@ABKq<qçè=ENlO·ÿ|HYwK HÎÏ=¸¹û°αK4;û4±² ô0 0z Ù==Ü\E¦N\^O H=²E5NWOHfc²05ÂW40NÂOH4²N5OWH²5hcWKF D XHèåfh(c−c<O−(Ha−Wch)G/
)H Kzë W−W> +WÖK ÎÏH=¸¹û°P\R =ENh(−(a−c)/
f<c−NO¸¹û°α\hc< )K W−W< K ÎÏH=fhc<cQÉÊRi=¸¹ÜBK=ENOH×.ëÂ400H4 Nt×OH½KÂ×Hf°~{9hq>q\K±lÉç·ÊKÿR|iH=~W9¸K¹ Ü$Gi ½ '"ÎÏ=¸¹\(α= )K¶=ENOH×sJû4bcK 4±² sÚK ûIWs0H4NO³4ìíTK\ KRôi=W¸¹sÚÜH=ENOú×=K· +±(α= )K¶=ENOH×s³L4=NEONHOH×W°DKMÉ0ÊÂ4NWOHWs0KK³R«Rm4×ì4NOfÑH@ABK4NOfÑH5{Kõ1ùû4±² ô=íTîïH8óëÂ00k½HYwK$G±k«qBÂúJ\ENOú×=\× ûëüÂN 04RN~O»H ×°K r =EKN OlHÃ-W^=0¸¹¾ôK¶=ENOH1;zû ô=ENO=Hz\ë¬ÐKK4NOHWFDKp0Â4NOHWRG 4=E;NûO4H±W² ÚôÂ=E4NNOO=HW\K006HYw±çK =ENOC4NOÂ4bc½uvCournot®×
_ `K¦^ =ENOH×ë{|ÂÞ4 N O H ¸4NO°GK4;Qû*^Nz ô=×KErN=OENOHOPMfÌÍ\¬ÐK¶4NOH×ëÂ=ENOH×KÉ=Êk4ÊË4HeOP¸=ENO#K 4;z~!ROPsSH=ENNOOH3Ê4HefÌ ÍK 4;û*4±² ô=ENOú=\Ë ¡¢£¤~090RR46N]KO$CG=EJN
OÿlÕ644bc;Kz`4=E;NSOI`=HENãO{ÜK¸0¹ CfѱßI4;=0³B´H-ÎÜÏ=¸Ô¹Ü\ó°=K»`=ENOIK XH=ENOf∗fpi=[αP+( ff−α)P]q−cq−t( f−αγ)q =ENOÔëãfÑHl¾"Õ°ff′∗pi=P+qP−c−t( −αγ)= f0000 4N4OH;f Ñ®ICfÑÔKëãHl¾"Õù·S XC X\4NOfÑ=KµTä4;`=EN4OeafI®³´TU4ìíTîïC®±ßó°«H·K
XHefhfW=U(Q)−PQ+pi+t( −αγ)q
4004°b´cHã¬Y~wK»$®G°ù{4~»®° 3» 4;HÎÏ\{P=a−bQK1R¯ÜH=¸¹αCptÐBK
XH4efß®à ±áßâãóä°åæçèéêëìíîæçïð ∗fW(α,t)= {[
( −α)a+b( αP−c−t( −αγ)−( h−α)c]−α)∗f+
[( −α)a−αP+c+t( h −αγ)−
( −α)c]+ t( −αγ)[( −α)a+
∗αP−
fc−
t( h−αγ)+( −α)c]} 00 ÎWÏ!=6H¸Y¹wû±°çPKpRp°PKef®W°=¸¹αH ®K% XHef®αH3Ì\Rj¶pt ÂPK1z²Ç!W°=¸¹αH 6 HdÎhÏu=v¸¸s¹Kù$°G3{Ì4\ RÎeÏf®®\÷L°´YwH+ ¯K ®KCWWù°=¸¹αHpK±R=¸¹°3ÌH@ABK°´»«ÎÏ®]K¸αs= òC@αA=BαHHeò@ABYÇ» ÎÏpKúÐ oefdfëI3»«ÎÏ=¸¹CÎÏpHÑ0\0l·ÿ|H4ÜK4;`=ENOHII¸¹ò\ DKR4;`=ENONq×YI°`Nq×HI@ACBK`¶É(γ= )=α°PK1 XHef®`t×Y±«ÎÏHp°t =t|γ= ,α= fa−c= > ú½X oef®K±«4HefÌÍ°W( ,t ( a−
)= fc
− h c)( a+
fc+b − hc)(a− fc+ hc)(+b
fa−c) b 00 4=NO¸¹Õ°α4bKc=K4N4OHØe÷fzÌ.KQ 4;H·°P\ Í°(W(α,t)= h a−c) b
0 0 XC Xw5±«{|Þ hfhfW( ,t )−W(α,t)=(c−c)[(a−c)+ (a−c)] 0 0 ½XXH]èKå]°ä9åKl¦ÃÉ°Ê9ÎKÏaHk=è¸å¹ û°PhKLfc−cwÔûÜH\Î Ïhcp>°fcKt =t|γ¸= ¹,αû= °f=(a−c)/ > ê¬ÐK¶hfc<cK1 XHèå°ÝKÎÏH=α\½Â~9K$G±k«qkBHúJ\ 4ûNüOVH 0W K41;4`=;EzNûO HôN=qEN×OIK¶=ENOHW0ÂWÚÂ4NOHWK14;û4±²= ô=ENêO¬=ÐK\¶=ENOH40±0² ½ôÂ=úEJN±Oç=K \=öE÷N ³«s=E4NNOOXHWK ° Ú4KH4;ûR¶I=ENOÉK.³4bc½OH±nW·ì?KfÑKak³L=ENOHWsÊÚKr4NOHENOÉ\å =E4NOHW°0Kõ1zûI=1i~NOHWs4NOHW°0K4;00 Kô =4K; ±`=EINOIÉ3 qYã=ENOfÑq4ÉHÅH\Â=ENON®ÉKÉ×Â(γ= )K¶=¸¹°PK1S\¶=¸¹°Nq×KdhC`Nq×IHdhw`Nq×IHα@K1A=wES\NO úúzJ.HdKhQ ±ÉÏü· 4°PKdhQCNOIÉHZA;`=El00$IG±ú6C\W!6Hdh[l¸s\W!6HYw±çKR4;r GHëq¥lH@FABKK³4L=;EQNûOJH\W=w¸`¹Â4LNOHWj^GH×É4bc\R6HYw±çKRI=ENOúNq=ENORW½s4;±IdtBK¦LI=ENON®×É44bNcO\j¦GjHKÂ1·4°;4eûfJH\l=qr¸K¹
4;`=ENOIßàáKâ¯ãä^å]æ³ç=èéEêNëOì8íîækç¯ï8ðó4·H ]³4;`=ENOs°
^H=¸¹K¦00ÎðK$G±ú=ENOÕ4bcH@AC=E\4bcH@A l¸s\¼½úJ!±NOº4NOÕ=¸¹±³«=çK =ENOÕ4bcK¦RKÎÏH=¸¹±E²NO°H9KC×=8EóNrOH4W;i|`_\=REjNRO=HEa^×I4NOÕ4bcH@ABKi94;|`=NOCK¦=ENOHWs4NOENOHÖ×pÉ×Ibc½>R4NO°ÚK1Ù ô=ENO=\¦j° ï5K4; i~ SÂmn ô=a_3HìíT{K\ìíTù^ HÒÓ K 4;s±²`=ENOü= ` a0¹0»ChaoòandYVuH
Ñld|ÒkJlKm3nGo
sHtRYIwt=ÃJ¸(¹)KCB¸HÎÏl j3ÌKRjÂRBLBK ;µK *|a«qH c¸¹°lb¬=>?@ABHܸ¹°PéK°]Mr=4M4FGNqOôçB00Rj*| Ñldm nllm9=H>=?¸¹\opHm×ðKk®~AB@AB4]çÀ4ÁéHHÎÏ4=I¸¹KC lm|óÎ0Ï0I|aЫVqHHÑldÒ;J\d 9=·KB\|d|\W´lqrB¸¹Hmn\cH@A\ DKRp=ÈÜ®~´=ENOÕ4b;`=ENOHr4H~» z H@ABK·h4IK1ÎÏ=ָ׹I°KP\1 Î=ÏH¸=¹=¸¹«±Ü²°K9ê4¶`=ENOHÉOI]¶4;`Ö×IK1ÎÏp;û*`=ENpKRgòI+XBHÖ×ûIÂ`ÉIHÎÏÜpC=¸¹H@ABKw¶SKÖ4·;Ce`f=QEwNSO\IRÉ4K;1SÎÏÔ=
¸¹°Pê¶4{|Þ 0;`=ENOHÖ×IK1ÎÏ=¸¹±²°9\H0@A\| Q®¶~´44;bc=mEnN=OC4NOÕ Cournot®×_`ÄNOHw`WLÜ\¶4NO¸H¹WKs1=ÎEÏNHO=0K1¸Î¹ÏH=Ù<¹j4±² ô=ENO=ê¬ÐK¶=EN¸NO°0rj^w ëHGHK14OHWs44;SÔÜ=¸¹CpK¶;û4*z;` =eE=NEONHON=q\×I KK O1= =ENOêH¬ÐKW¶=0EÂNO4HNOHWWK4;zû ô=EN;±û`4=±E²NO Iô=ÚÂ4NOHWK14;EKNO4=;\ûw`s=ÂEN^O`=EsN°O
I^HH=@A¸K¹ 4\f ghkijÁGuisinger
niijjllCHhearaonadnedraYnud T
h\
o m als |
H¨m\oE·F]G4RëìÛ\Ç%`=¾E¿FÞGva- Ü HCíRäod \Orikp l
K¶ ï g]|HÜ]~]9\4;`=q;+I\¶=EFGú==EFGÉKúwK$G{4K1R¾¿qI\°´+¯Yòt4;±²`=ENONq×Ip`ÉIrbÿ|Wy\ Ê<KRR46;Hsvt=] ¸i¹HÅH|st=3AB.`4NOt benchma4NOK 6Hst±<°ljmsuvijÁChaorka n\dYu
` a W²5W08\«öÜ÷H½{Â4H {L4رK³$G H±Üñµl\mã{4=ENOH²5Ha^d9K °´®(x8½H|ØHÅsÆtKñ$óGlkmsãKwHz{.4ßuàv~|9Y\w
y|}½x8ßàáâãäåæçèéêëìíîæçïð
IK·L4;`=>?@ABNOIH+Xë ^!ò]lºz
ê!ºevIyanfdÑNolaKn·
K
a êgºI×K·BranderandSpencer|{44;`=ENOnt
CBondandSamuelson
\z|]KBaIH°×\{
XHlë¾ "ÉÕ×±Y \æ∗f′∗fP−P−( −α)qP+tγ=[(P−c)−t( −γ)]/( −α)<| R`\ÐÍ g8 g°ghWü}g~®HH~å{9Ú4±²BjHKÁX²Ë5gü.
 n\o©ªK′U=PKak±ú .S p e nëcXer±ßó°\t=−[( f′′′f−α)q][P+( −α)Pq]/( −αγ)K K
Î Ï l|pa°«9\ =¸¹ÏpB ra nder′′Panzα°PK Îdzj H@ABK qpH°Î9Ïpbf′f− t=−q[P−(dq/dt)]KR~»
Rlmz^N_`Hst]K¶\ °ÝpçNO Cournot®×_`K1lmaÁ¬ûú X Ï
éH"Õ°~» zj \Hl¾"ÕwSKnX°K±«=ENORγ= Cγ= ò@ABÔÜ×f∗ffαP+( −α)P−c+qpi= \½X] ff¦ÉÂÊRlæHγK|{γÜ== CENγ=O qò4@?A@HAÎBÏ|pÂÐRBK4=ENOH×wS\cK R4;l ô4NO=H@AbcHfÚÂb z.=\RÞ5H@A]K³BK$Gt8{44NO4NOù^±²=K4R4bcHfÚÂbcKl` aÊ567]Ð dumping K[TEÂNO4Hf;Ña°4ÝHJ =HæÁ¼¸Ìq¹\rzN±®²°Úqø KY ÐK°^N ô=.³=BK1|HYwi´µ\°³=ENO=ENOØz.ÿ3?@A°lI HαÝ\α±=ENOHfÑz°ÝK=¸¹H½¾ØOBf|ÑH°®P(±YÌw«HPfÑ"Õ»«K§ XH=ENú%αØ= (PV\f∗−c)/(P−P)∈( , )\
{|Þ α= K=ENOH×°h(a−
fc+c)/ b\×°9H"ÕÇ%´ha−
fc+c> \Þfq5|α=½ jh−q|αw=` WhHÚf=(c−c)0/b\K α= KNO×ëIHHÔÜ ¡B¢£ ¤¥¦§¤¨©ª
«¬®¯°±²³´µ¶·¸«¹º»¼«
«½−−−−−−−−−−Boranndd aen E rd WD
i rae¾nJ A cdtaFnLod rSeBaig mnuelson
BargainingwithCommitment ChoiceofTechniques J InSvpeesntmceernt
J o
u r n alofInternationalEconomics
BCrhaanodI enCrt erJn atAio naanldEcBo noJm ics
TradeWarfare Tari andCartels Journalofand CE ndanodgeEno uSs HTa xYeSspueanncder
T a r i
Es x p Joo ruFt ronsrhaelaigroenfRIDnetieqrreunciatretiImonnevaenlsttsEmaceonnndtoUmwniictehsm U n e m p l o y m
entChao CaCs eCof QanudotaEs SS oHut heYrnuE c o
n
o m ic CJoounrtnal ployment TheCDhao WCe lfaCr e a nCanadianJournalofEconomics e n t
P r o d
u
c ti on UrbanUnemploymentandJointVentdureEs S JHou rnYaulo f
I
n te r n aAtireWhollyForeign ownedEnterprisesBetterthanGauvisiidnDsgoiernre cCtS F oSEr e Jig MatuszandM E Kreionninal E
c o n o m Aicns al
y si s o f P e rf o rmanceSt n
I n vestments CanadianJournalofEconomics
andardsforHHyemraenIRrdn eteeqSrru n iMati oGna lanTrdadCe R P rIonTdvhueosctmtmioaensn t a nI
nd c eI nn tvivesandPerformanceRequirements Patternsof eEstxmpoenrtt PNerefowrmYaonrkc eaPnradeEgexrp ort impor r e
m e n t sT hQeuInatreternrlaytiJoonuarnalofEconomics
tLinkageInvestment DoctoralDissertatlioOn peMraItTio nMsIoTfNPraetisos nalFirms AStudyofDirectForeign
Kant C
MultßinàatáionâalãFäiråmsæaçndèGéoêveërnìíîæçïð Kindlenboemrigcesr
C
mentRevenues JournalofPublicEco Levy HSa vaennd SY alNePo Ul a nn
iv
AmericanBusinessAbroad SixLettersonDirectInvestment NewLiu BJ ou e r
s
it y P reTsrsa deandForeignIJ rn a l
o f D eTvehloepEmceonntoEmciocnIommpiclisc a ti o n o f E x ponrvteRstemqeunirtePmoelnictiesunderCompetition Rodri ok f
ED c o n o
m ic s s EconomicEssays T h e E c o n o m i csofExport performanceRequirements QuarterlyJournal
{|Þ THOEPTOIMPTAILMTAALXERXAPTOERTU NSDHEARRIEMREQUIREMENTSANDTHEDepartmJPERFECTCOMPETITIONATeasinusmtnonUkoc eafiaRongChiounnI ntgedHUuPesnrotirfieaslsEocronomuateInTsatimtukteanoJvaenrsityicsGradMafsIntedrustrialEconomicsABSgTRUAnCivTersity¿Thispaperexplorestheoptimalpolicycombinationofexport–sharerequirements(ESR):Ifthehomecountrygovernmentimposesaunittaxonlyonsalestothedomesticmarket,’stotaloutput,,,wealsostudythecasewhentheforeignanddomesticfirmsareaduopolyinthedomesticmarketandengageinCournotcompetition:IfthehomecountrygovernmentimposesonlytheESR,,thenwhentheforeignfirm’scostislowerthanthedomesticfirm’s,
ßàáâãäåæçèéêëìíîæçïð theforeigninvestor,:ForeignDirectInvestment,Export–sharerequirementspolicy,Theoptimaltaxrate
