1a*- z m/ - v s`|VlT:TKTO05(Æ xy 06(h/wixy j b 22007( Se"℄{rn lj n _8f HWF pP 5 8*& 1$_4ggD o0n ? E
X SD ! i
\IeQf%O N n
%Oo nut B q℄ _8f +8f CÆ8fnk n 'C9 n d ~ G jn 5m^ kab60000Y_n;, .kU`Z7 _}z r =7mh07(G +8f”)8”nkU`Z E
j.<u#q83dp wJa>! CÆ8f^+8fnL
[M $ pP 56 R wJIeQf%ON n
%OXD * >0AFactorsanalysisonliquiditysurplusandariseofChinesestockmarketsTianBoping,FangLeiDepartmentofMathematics,HarbinInstituteofTechnology,,150001AbstractSinceExchangeRatioReformin2005,aswellasShareholderStructureReforminearly2006,,liquiditysurplus,stockpricebubble,,inthispaperthereareeconometricmethods(Error-correctionModel,VARModeletc.)toanalyzeamultitudeofdomesticandforeigndata,includingdatainmonetarymarkets,stockmarkets,,itestimatethattherewasabout6000billionyuansurplusofcapitalinChinesemacroeconomy,-CorrectionModelVARModel7N2007Æ p :E ÆJ{ T" C6j06Æ !Æ k>"t>F gr!m
3 DÆ
g| 5( W< TkV}2wD [(E0_ 9USD/RMB YR$1: 2 4jw F S Tkx _F '< v I)4O$_A2|w<rbJ?BA 94:2008-12-11[YK1:&
rnR-;E la 6 G200815fl+, "12 $ !;# W; [ ; ime2008Æ;f9F z5 f;flzWql&p \V#':HA# :={Q ;!;_y hj a8yB ℄Y :={Q ;ÆH; S WMÆHeQC E-mail:bopingt361147@ GB :={Q ;hjm !HOY% B E b!H ^
2` k-_(+Et ÆA Q eKA 0m E ℄kSbrQ6k. Q =^
V:4xz5 '
k-_(+ xoD rWo _(+ x
W<wDoD\a
V:℄xvO .T <lu# _(+ Tu
^ V:℄(8& y P K|
A2Kl
p h V
jPt$
Q _(+ x +'
al)m +%b _(+ Y lJ l)Pi#6M KV#"[1] 83
3Q ) V x EL F9 /zI
V:℄ X_(+ x k 30Z_ w 9za# V:℄# X_(+ xk I 12Z_ #" } Qh' EL V:43 _(+ x3p ℄ T|*Æ T v jEL j THN V:4 INLgq, i TQ| T 5 k ^THN V:4NFhp F V7k.
A2 5?r P~
Q '5P V ZaV}2 wD ' `,kv V": Q ℄ TkSbr kw z u4 HN:4N$V}2wDÆt \ pxÆ qk \\- ){Æ {Æ g d t p ) VÆW7 _(+ x _(+ x k-Æ5p 8
k. j~tJ P~ k. i Æ~t W< T
T1vBd v a$ Q 36 D{ A 3 p V=N |*Æ8"$UA2=N jVM a
M( -k8EV": vSpD
A2|wT Ki WjC}Pk F D V}21w <i iA2 T T"W< T T WÆ, T, ,
vG z VXT: D?3
),PZLD` x ) V:Q^ A2 TD`X1 Xhp _(+ xk-[2] pxKz Tm8 & VAR
:Gl(CointegrationTheory)"uQ.< &(ECM)A
A2|w"6g W_b T1
F ~ Kz Tm8 &(VAR)"QN Tm8 &(DVAR)A VV}2wD
dBd Æ. ~ ?zr? i ~fH(GrangerCausalityTest)=?V k. *8 i ":.P d Ki7(
[3-5] v,gMy)a ℄: x,3p v '5:43p T") V ~xVA X F 2005
[6]A ; yW&) p F 71
) Vv7T 71ÆY%GlNv T <' ' `,kÆU> ) V <'" ℄) V=N Æ FnE
YJ\a7Ax) V < ; ia |d/.
:;
hr4 T{ ,h ok 2002
[7] V A ; ) V /g8 A2|rT KA 071i .P /g8Bd|
Vx Z "ZÆY% W&&( ~ R8[8] 3 b (
V / (
) :A <
1994Æ7 Z3 b (
) V /71E| W&&( ~ 6
p ZÆm% W:4 b (D{ A \ ÆTd px A Fama 4Fq & Vaga 1991
Æ<'-<TU(O: & *D- `Æ k- T br di U
dipDÆ} WH D- V4 D- X
" Pk4 KE=5 PW)a#"
6Sti, %6$' )a ℄:℄[9]K 3w T"F S TbrF ( A FhVx #G)a q:U/ Un i, v W yU '5|+Æ ℄ T X ( TtVM i pxqKz7 Gl3 HSÆQ TygM Nv kQ6 OÆ, T," , < Q ) 3 ZGa|d i k>"t>o%F N<<m k >Kv℄6"t|>Kv℄6[* m V}21w < Q W<
G [* =WM(
- L <
6g_(+ x ÆF 5 A2PKT 6 5 k /M<1Pkhd Æ VPk/ V T
ZLKA 0_ T
A2|w
vSpD /M2/GDPÆTt ℄+ZL _(+ x 0F9 jvBWO V:4whV*8EL F9 Map I))WX oFh 0_(+ PTtF9 jPl)Y6i) [10] S-1Æp yk \ {Æ Z<M2/GDP 71 )hp A2|w $W 4 V $W -2006 eq M2/GDP .℄N ^ CM2/GDP 82L*8 ℄y/z )hm2000ÆZ<p M2/GDPm j l BZW *8 ℄ l BM2/GDP'm.
8 A2 M, 9\-ia V $ZB,*I)& SK ; A2|w D?<wI * V” 0” 6Z\- M2/GDPOTCzm Qp _(+ xk-Æ| 6Y 5 V:℄ ~LZL Æ3 _(+ xk T V:4x 1 ÆQ' kKzA2 TD`< 1hp xk-T ?Zl)E~ | 5Q6ya\`F9 - L <,
!
4
:4+Zap | j_(+ x EL:4 1 ThbNLVmRB jV uQW \M OTD? EL T $< za9i O V$Z D?+Kz V:Q^ A2 TD` x A2 TD`M∗V=P∗Y,*QM; A2|w V; A2_K/, P; Shtb Y ; TpSh OZGDP z7( N/ ( ; a ∆M+∆V=∆P+∆Y(1)A2\
: as.& A2_K /,ÆE7 O.& ∆V=0 ÆD`g1a ∆M=∆P+∆Y=∆CPI+∆GDP1=∆GDP2(2)6IGDP1,GDP2N< ;ZGDP"
GDP 2vD` OA2|w
vSpDMLG$W S' Vp v PÆGDP
A2|wM2 $Wg8 2A2 Tl
)hp _(+ xk- | -2007 q GDP M2%Xj bTpx8EV2000ÆZ< T,M2
GDP|d3X Z2000ÆaDiÆ Oas2000ÆE| xk- vB3A2|wÆY%D` 1
?as2000ÆZ<A2_K/,ÆE7 }v< Xp _(+ xk- T,3X } M2ÆTU|T
GDPpxKzqvT,L3gtT, T,C_ D [Ba'T,C_GDP EIg[aGDP SÆX1
'T,C_GDP $Wi *QG1; GDP$Wi G2; M2|w$Wi 6I$WiÆT,L/$Wi Kz $Wi 2000ÆaDÆ Dlkx D` 2
.Z A2 TD` 9i T,|d3X Æ _(+ xk-T _(+ xk-T=Z M2- A2 TD` 9i M26J X1 _(+ xk-T 07Æ!;T,|T a6Z_ w aSa <
2006Æ x k-Æhp O Æ$Æ/ *8ÆS 2006ÆA2|wEÆ;, A9Æ 5 )h6T# 06ÆS V$Wi m A2|w$Wi 6
Q VNX 1E~71 v 3px X_(+ x Tv E
} *7ÆSA2|w 4$W y9 K_(+ xk-CGT ; yaTU\`+F9 pxX1 V2003Æ8 J2005Æ11 ℄l)E~ | 5Q6 8AxVp q: } k Lg8 .Zya_(+ xk- Ttz ,T
2000 [= (U-D` %Xj d 06 W%X{+9}' _% j/ q GDP!2 82Æ.~B3!UEaY2 `), .`), y℄aG:–m*F } R7
)h}v k- xTLk{zA2 TD`X1 xk-'ÆÆ) } 06ÆSÆA2 5 07Æ3ST,A2;, .ZU1h
3p ) VQ| _(+ xk-Oreo5 6Z_ #" - L <
SP Q p 2006Æ3 PÆdM2Æ3 V b64/ $WÆ \_(+ x \M i Glks v M2_(+ \Mi,ÆDlA2<)T"A2_ DlA2<$ 3 V TA2T PKkTt + F9 a I)# _(+ x 8Æ.ZhpA2PKT<1MQ ) T VQ A2T Æ T# } Q 6PÆW<m)b6 X$W I)E E3vÆ 6 W<m)
)e 6 Q$_VDlA2 <)T {:z ) W<m)(5 /V[n$ S7QMRESF A2_ a3 W<m)6r A2 ) W<m) X$WT'`,k \Vp
A2|w 4/$W y9 \k-_(+ x . M2-X=)6)/GDP =n*s! B3 M2 0{
QO THN V:4Fhp A2|w:5 \_(+ x \M iÆA2_ $
9K V) VQ A2pT Fh A2_
?'|5i) i jPl) Y6|5i) i"
3|5 /i+\VA/ ~ v gÆQ v jPl) Y6|5i) i"
/i+
7h
VEL`, t
?'i) iOE0%m A2_ 2006Æ [%[1] 64Q KA2 x_(+ N"$W Q _(+ x (\ O T' WHi, /aw V$WK6K wPmJHVw| wG \ #W&
b\Ki 4 Ki Z ℄auH-2wDG= KqVCmKi s ivT V:4ZaJ?;,+ A2=N wI V`+ L| GCV T_(+ 96*Q % HN+_bZQ a ; ?Z!% VE i9 \Vp _(+ x x Z V: Gl 6?g
Xh PÆ< Z T T1 _b[10](HM-T, ) HM=∆RES−NX−FDI(3)yGlk<$ 6tD?3T1 XÆzzk ia6tD?u ,h Q \N\IPkD 3jPl)
k W<m)QELA2<i Æ371 ZL V QtV<8 W< i, i9SvT' uQ i 8 ℄My+ px5ÆK 6?9L Z "(;?< Xp ℄ TQ T1 Q = U2 `
bTT1(HotMoney/RefugeeCapital) [k |PF+.&k- IaZv U h vm%f9 Z ℄ Tk=/_( .&PF+k 4j Æ<p s℄ 3W'K"k- 'K`, Cm |*ÆV}2wD Æ& ZT1[G T_b 3Q
3T1 5z 5E:3 V ℄n' \ _ 40 4 fT1_/_b A Z5zT13p V ℄n' eC 2. ?:U
PB H PÆ< < 5 W:4A Q T[11-14] :4aDidierSornetteas bF T|d/ Y%F &$W tA whVTU X & *z Q >A <
' 5 :4Fh p W ℄ T ( v z m05Æ INLgqZ< p Th
Vm\NZ<v F gr!m
=^5xjÆ h
.&9 + EbF kw Q k>F q:
{ lQ ,R$4000 5000"6000# Æ KD'- 9/ J kX$|&+m ui"k-_(+ x )-Æ v O > jVT HN V:4Za D-{ 5 :4+Za | 2E ?
%px/zT L& W Tg8 F 9D Æ/ < ℄ p Tm06
8ÆQ&Z<OÆt " y o,<'Q ℄Æ/ F k. EÆ t4V 93 p D/GDP yS-10Q:z ) 2006Æ3p DÆ/ GDP < ℄ OLJ o," y
3p D 25Z_ w
ÆÆ p D
GDP/Dre 1 6[ < ℄ #" "<'Q ℄o, yÆ/O?E1m
sG!# E/GDPM
+9℄N ^ G! 0{a $p TÆ4/k. J?!% VE T THN px E
g
Z'p T| ?_D*I 4jp ℄ T [G'K T:z5 J? ℄ T v pxrez5
p T ℄EM Yi y95z h 4*7 ℄ Tdy Kp T"V .
IMp ℄EMlJV
O5z v `, 5 ?:USP
H 6tW$Q~ oD pxyPtEL x,<Nv*.
i pxIO _(+ xk-`UV F m/k. 9x k{ Nv _(+ x i\M ℄A2PKT 5" WT1_b$5 6J ` g K|F T A2ybp T y9 \Vb6 07Æ x W:4 D{ Nv V}2 wDpEk<$3p v ÆK 6ZV}2 4/wD[( 4OÆwI k. TtVM i %*7D{ Nv {px\MyA2|w T1_b V}2wD Ki7(ZLUnU/bD{
) ?l C pxIO T _(+ xk-reÆU( V. \M i 9 5 A2|wÆk- x \Mi, 6ZpxV#,PA2|w3 v Zv<Ax_(+ x3 v px8EV2000J2007Æ6 dk> SHANG
"t> SHEN
o%F bZL ,
A2|wTM2
f _
<,P ,h_
A2|wT3k>"t>o%F 7( v O,PM
MS"MZ ~ *QM=D(M2) SH=D(SHANG) SZ=D(SHEN) D(); QN K r? i ~fH(GrangerCausalityTest) pxA M7(ÆSH"SZ7( i Table1Grangeri ~fH
9J- 1-89P, 2 as
α= ^ 8z Tm8 & VAR
,PM3SH v SH=(−1)−(−2)+(−3)+(−1)+(−2)+(−3)−[][−][][][][][−]R2=¯2===(−1)+(−2)+(−3)−(−1)−(−2)+(−3)+(4)LJ hM
SZ Tm8 & SH=(−1)+(−2)+(−1)+(−2)−[][][][][−]R2=(5)¯2===(−1)+(−2)+(−1)−(−2)+
[]ÆtNXT } \M,PA23 v D`QI9hk>"t>F D` T NXT D` P, }SICi#"RNXT~L$' Z D`Lk yD` 4
" 5
.Z) A2|w7(3k>"t>F 7( v Æ' ^ SH"SZ+"3S& A2|w$_6 J* ^ <Æ +
A2|w$_6Æ/kT&v51_ k "t| F &# }
A2|w3 v ' gB, p ) V TQ 5 A2TÆ_/ k. TtVM i {Kz :Gl"uQ.< &<,PM
SHW&&(".&(; ~ } :ÆoN |d3XL"n DlBk M3Zk3X
)
fxfH ADF
a Table2
fxfH 7TADFD5%[ D1%[ D % ^I(1),5% ^I(0)D(M)% ^I(1),5% ^I(0)% ^I(1)D(SH)% ^I(1)
ADFfH":V E":A P, v DÆ3 |d3XM SH+ÆT
:
) :fH 3"3X
)Johansen :fH Table3Johansen :fH λH0:rank=rHNXT5%[ Dλmax[ == :~ M::
Johansen :fHas TtO'+ +A E":A P, 13
10Johansen :fH; 5%#" %rank=0 } rank=1 OM
SH| TtW&&( : T
O M
SH| W&&( : ~ }v ECM(M)=M−,ECM(SH)=SH−(6)q* buQ.< &Q D(SH)=−(M(−1))−(M(−2))−(M(−3))−(SH(−1))−(SH(−2))[−][−][−][−][−]+(SH(−1))+[][]R2=¯2===(M)=−(M(−1))−(M(−2))−(SH(−1))−(SH(−1))+(7)
D` 4
5
EL 7
Tt,
O.&(;Q
Æ
Æ 3t>F A ÆL
a6Æp 3 A2|wT4/$_ TU
{A9 1Æia T
{ l +(+=N9 \ "86 QJ Z Tk_( k-ÆZh[m8% m davT 9 Q TÆ< w ZPF4xTR T6 b6k.
{nV Tk-_b 9_b Zk- A <:{
br m/k. 8E2006ÆZ<W<m)RES h2EX
2IM"WjC}Pk , Kz &(3).ZX1 2006Æ1 J2007Æ7 d ZT1 ,3X OHM=∆RES−NX−FDI=∆RES−(EX−IM)−FDI(8) [= [ U2 `
l?G!8) ) T1 71Æ℄ k> F 7( ?6S47(G%TK ,PHM3SH"SZ v % ~ SH=−(−1)−(−2)++(−1)+(−2)[∗][−][−∗][∗][∗][](9)R2=¯2====−(−1)−(−2)++(−1)+(−2)[∗][−∗][−∗][∗][][∗](10)R2=¯2===
11
∗; 5%#"k ^ yk{StD`.Z)h ZT1HM3k>
t>o%F 7( v SH"SZ+
HML*P,D ^<Æ ; gZ< Zk- _b3 `Up k.- VÆ
yz Æ 3 QJ05Æ<gB, V}21w b6wD 6wDX,E0$ 3QV}21w wD3 y 3wh2 .PÆEK 3 p ) VD-{ZL{nWk_b+ < v p <)V}2 wD3 v ÆK {<,PV}2wD
di Æ. ~ px8EV2006Æ5 8\ 2007Æ10 24\d k>"t>o%F ZLV}21w |d3X J-T~360t '
vG di N/=100∗(lnpt−lnpt−1),vG V}21w wD N/=100∗(Et−1−Et)/Et−1.}v k>"t|o%F vG di3X shang shen
ZLUSD/RMBvG wD[(|d3Xe K
fxfHpx<
7x+Æ"n3X Table4shang shen"e
fxfH 7TADFD5%[ D1%[ D % ^I(0)% ^I(0)% ^I(0)
ADFfH":V E":A P, v DÆ16Kz Tm8 & VAR
,Pshang"eyaTt T|d3X8xBd ~ shang=−(−1)−(−2)+(−1)+(−1)+===(11)e=(−1)−(−2)−(−1)−(−2)−===` 11
.Z ) shang"shen D` % /z k>
t> di3X
V}21w wD[( ^<Æ e3shang3X v ~ LV V}21w wDq: K4,SG di ^Cm D` di3V}2wD 7( v ^-*^ ElÆk>oF vG di 5Æt> vG di 3V}2wD[( v ~ + ^ 5% #"iv p V}2 wD3 k. j' GJyz A < p 3V}2wD v ?E| jyaTU/z pxzQN Tm8 & DVAR
A V di"V}2wD3X (; ~ D(shang)=−(shang(−1))−(shang(−2))−(shang(−3))−(shang(−4))+(e(−1))+(e(−2))−(e(−3))−(e(−4))(12)
(12)Q D(e)D`Q D(shang(−2)) D(shang(−3))"D(shang(−4)) ia~ : 9u Xh< shang"e DVAR &
vE) u wh shang"e DVAR &(12)OLJo0px<iwD 7(3 k>oF di 7( v Æ ^ A <k>oF di 7(3V}2wD [(u v +.
QJ
12px<
H fjÆQ q
.&KiBdOE| 6Æ&
Æ yGlk$ Ki tt Vk \-"3
i $ Pk iv:{
brk. ABKi kw: > b .Æ N$VQ h y2004Æg 2005ÆÆQ
.&Ki t |+ NÆ & y2005ÆQ& 2006Æ> Kikw A9 E0 w HgÆQ Q
Ki ~YJEÆGl6Æ& J[21] pxy {:k ) 6U
ElÆ>K Tk 1t 8 Ki
5Æ7G8 Ki
Glk+
q ÆA -2007 l? -G!r
?L U1u 9 Lj82T Q )h p A kKi
k>o%F P-Æ<Æ
b2007ÆZ< v
I) }'T%7FCm|5i) i _|B, brE E: ~ N\\h
Tt k R$ 6TD{ rWoAxVp E\
EYi _|=N 7FE E: l)A8Q } Q T _(+k N\aTU$| O' }Æ$.& =N n'+
9$_V3 T="$# \_| , F k R$ ^TD{ pxre
a I) _|=NZkÆF 5K| \ Pk }℄K hpPk |*ÆF S)P
<3 Vtj ℄kSbrm. Tk .& .PE:ia_|9K03Ke h[ 6ZE:hpPk 9\M
13v }|5 >&|5K|?u $_ _kzm KA 0i Q } QE:ia_|9 k F' T 5 ;R x w V:℄nDB }A
Un U/3 v Gl p
4/9b6 k.'.
Æiap q:U/ UnY fV V Tk T EL |& jEL q:Un p \N T3, 205ÆdTC#bm/ V$W INLgq3=^3 O 5x%: a~tÆ/ Z3
i q:U/ 71 =^K INLgqZL l 7p pxza
T $_V3 T T="$# T fB}4y Q?K *7VQQ J q:U/ (\V iaPk4M> br X$0 > k# 7x aj v `.
|*! q:+ T q:#G:k l VtV v "PE >O O”m( ( r” V:u<”8wGl”<|
X` V/a7( L + <lj |
O:=EmÆ _b } 2sQH 6ÆTUU/ (\ 4j \W
V <'64Qh
4j U/ 7 83 v O[n$ < 5 } +R#GZL3 brkw Æ& :`Uj br 4/kw 9 b 4/kw6 < d z U/ A < U(j k. U/ pST K br<v 6UU/ Æ Æ& br V q:(;v vVM i<m TL
4 P"q:#G: q::" Tt :k ^
h< VE G+ q:( D( > .
ÆL
T 3 k%G V V $WZLPk4" GjBd ~ 71 Q
3 Q q:d
~ 3D PkFb T kwZL }'/T I$+Æ* 7 > &/K Zk A Nv px Z l 3 {PÆ<p M2/GDP ,P ZLL *8<
<'Q ℄ 3/ p ) VQO| jk- _(+ x x A2 TD`Gl X2007Æ VQ _(+ xk om 6Z_ #" \`F9l)E~ | Q6>V6T l _(+ x i\M W<m)(5 4/$W \A2|w 5 2. 5A2|wT \_(+ x L| OU(Vp k. * 4/k. i \M p PÆ< 5 A2|w" W”T1”_b $_ 6 _(+A2 INLgqBFyb T|4Q \p T 4/k. ÆA 8x=/ Zh`: \ dy
jvBW g kq .
+ q:Un
U/ fV V}2wDÆ k. ^TtVM i }21w wD' `,kwIVk>
t>oF di Cm 3 p v ÆK A < di Cm3 V}2wD?u ^ v 83Zk lpxwhT oe -_(+ x 5q K ℄kSbr b64/kw I)re6qhpA2T PK )o A2=N<t VQ k-_(+ x zVM Æt KA 0 ) _|=NreCm }m2|5 >&K| 9E Æ.P 5K| W#?E
3 Vtj I:3l)E~ K | |Q$
3.=^M OYip ℄ T? M, 5r ℄EvS! <NhPk4 Pk 9 N
14kS L ℄Ev!3_(+ x T' \Myz ÆHB ℄U / )GI[1] `), y W;{ ."9 -J & ,[N].Newyouth-financeandeconomics,[2]*[M.`), y -U ℄ ^,[J].ChinaFinance,2007,19:49-50[3]-
q, N. ;Hm A) '.;0 ;i :51-110[4]Cm9,L
,}e4Y-p &Ms{.n y
i r,:76-85[5] 4,f>_ . ^ U ,> .l J ;i [6]Y G,Y
G! * W8U
^.2005 "08'ZhouHY,[J].ShangHaiFinance,2005,08:12-15[7]-i ,pl .R
G! * w j- ;
B .Æ W-;.2002 "06'ZhangWG,-integratedRelationBetweenChina’sStockPriceIndexandMacroInflu-encingFactors[J].ModernEconomicScience,2002,06:7-11[8]S9,^ U
sA) WA)[J].OY;,2000,2:7-8YeQ,[J].statistics,2000,1:7-8[9] W~ ;i r,200705:3-53[10],,,2002[11],(2000)79-97.[12]:AResearchHandbook,WorldScienti8c,Singapore,2003.[13]ZhouW.-X,’(2004)243-268[14]ZhouW.-X,,Evidenceofaworldwidestockmarketlog-periodicanti-bubblesincemid-2000,PhysicaA330(2003)543-583.
