201 2 3
∗
! "#$%&19'92000()*9+,-./
!01
2345 67!89 :;<=->?@A1
BCDE4FG 2!DH4F IJKL-MNMOP !QRS+, TUVWIJXY$Z[\]^_`1 aC
!bcde fVW-\] / !gh4F ijk-N1 +F G1 lm !bc VWnde- aC o
2! pqrs$Z[tuv-
uw x !yz_d$ 1
{ { !
! "#$ %&' () *+ $ ,- ./012345 6789: ;< $ = "#>7?@ A BCDE FGHIJKindleberger 19 6
2McKi n1n9o 6Kn3Mel t1z9e 7r:LM6 +N@OPQ BackRu1s9S95Kose &Y TUViW XY2Z 001 *[ \]^ _`
a& [bcd
efghiej k lm jK = "#%&'nop;:$q&r sj tA uvwWx yz:i Fran
Rkeo ls1e9 9$8Ko
sYe i20 0{|}6~'K
W21OEC lm D $ "#%&' ! p; ! np;' 6L $i "#%&'Vn:Cla
rvkan W i2n0c o0 o1plm jnoW + Gh¡¢+ ! "#%&':£¤
¥¦§ 20 1¨ 0 {¡¢
© $ª ∗
300 2 2E2-m aliulenzhu acno@ @ 24
201 2 3
«¬ ®~¯°PQ {|
Wlm $ "#%&' p; lm ±bno:²³
´µ
¶·¸ 20 1¹&¬1UVW $OEC !lmD * "#%&' noº»: L¼½¾ K¿ÀÁ½ @O ª ÂÃÄ Å{ PÆ Ç CÈÉ $ "#%&'():Fidr m20u 0c
2GrubRe n20 0
2ShiRn 20 0
4ʵËKÌ·Í 20 0 A 4Î p*<lm K¼½! ¼½¾ * "#%&' Ï:Ariel BuRr 2st0e 0i n8UV lm * "#% ' ÐÑÒÓ Blm¿ÀÁ½ "#%&'Ô ^ Õ&Ö ×Ø ¿À
!^ * "#%&' ÙÚ Ó <ÛÜ×Ø !^ ÖÝÇ Þßàs %&'áà : Fâ 3A sã»~e
{|älm ej
¼½¾
¿ÀÁ½ Rå ÈÉ * "#%&' ÐÑhiæ~?ç:èÖ ejé=êëìW ¼^Ní
j
îï ðj «NÔñ x«NÔñ p*òóhiôõö k ¨7÷ îøj k ÐÑ ! "#%&':Ôq ejùGúûüý7÷ "#%&' þ Ô: * Òz A fÓ ~ « m={
:Øð' ½ @O óÓéU»~ á ¨
{ m= the extensive m $þ am=rgin othf et riandtensive m aþ mr=Fgin of tradeG {jm=$îïm= Hum mKelelsnow : 2 00
5 Ü 20 10®~HS {
üýW
m=
ôõÒÓ <þ m= m= ÙÚ : ª 20 1 0¨
þ m={îïm=$jm= G
« m= !
ôõ"# <jm= m= a&$áW
%öôõ Öîïm=*
ôõÙÚ :ä
½
¼^« ¯ m={| <&ô ;
½jô'
¼^í|ô'Sþ m=¹{| < 3 ;
¼^() *+ê, -, ½-,N¼^
j ôõ: ¼^ ¯ >. ¼½! @O/0¼^ &ð¼^ ÒÓ. ^jôõ* ÙÚ 1jm=S¿À¼½¾ @O/0¼^ Øð'¼^ ÒÓ. ^îïôõ 1îïm=SÛܼ½¾ @O/0 ^2<&ð¼^$Øð¼^ ! ¼^îï$¼^jq34õ 53
¼^Ní ô'67û8 j ô' Ôq'. m=: nè Õ& m=*[bcd 9» 3:Õ& 7÷i* "#%&'¼;Õ& ÐÑ:Ôq <V« m=* "#%&' 25
æ~º= *<çX2>*' ,-?;óÓ:èÖ x@¯ A ABCå BergKiLni n20 1 0DEF¢GHlm m=I*øKp*ø noô' *F¢$J! "#%&'¼;ÀK-!K ÐÑ: 20 1 A0 ¡ Å "#%&'r LWlm m=6 MNOP{Qlm m=* "#%&'23no Rº»:xSA 0O ¬TUKþ ê TV WWs XY!: &GZ A Õ& [ ®~Hum
mKelelsn 2o0w 0 5« m={
\]FranKkeRlo s1e9 9lm 8 6 ^_` Laj !lm m= m= 6 b ±c de $iÒÓ lm m=
îïm=$jm=* "#%&' ÐÑ hi×Ø' Gf ,-. úû'$3º' g = , ÷': G ij k"#bO* lm'nz 1 "#%&' o @p Ghlm m= 6 LSèM * $iÒÓ "#%&'hilm m= qr'sét{QSÖ LP *+ê * m=$ "#%&';t
j{QSuMv O:
"#%&' Business cycle sæynqcXrh#¾ pr; o nization"#w xy @zK {ê:| }&' M~ G !é= lmp;'Co :p;às ! "#% ' à £¤
¥¦§ 20 1:0 * "#%&' o GZ A ã}~Æ 1 X9k T2d−dd−d∑()()i,ti,jtjt=1 Cor=r ij 1 22TT2d−dd−d∑()∑()i,ti,jtjt=1t=1 i Cor|ri $j éGDôõP p; dKd{||iji,tj,t éGDôõP: nÖ â ê
@p7{r!k * p;' ÐÑ:uá éU{Q 7 ~¯PQ äÖWr!k óÓ': \] 26
201 2 3
Cerq
uMeiarar t2in0s 0 9@p ^+r# "# p;Cor r7ij,tus 8Vr!oø Ã7 ~¯° {Q@p+ "#%&':tr#i
j p;CorB r
Æ 2 vk ij,t2d−dd−d()()1i,ti,jtj Cor=r1−− 2 ij,tTT222dddd∑()()iti∑jtj=1t=1 CorrWr! k ' $CorpròW23 n 17ijtij| Þ+ ! Rp;; Gh Þ¾ ! "# Ø'K Xr# &':èÖ xN
@p ¡ < :vkj ¢p; Cerq
uMeiarar t2in0s 0:9
lm m= 6 0
ÒÓ\]Feen 1st9r 9a
4HummKelsKlen 2o0w 0;< 5 Þß « {
1¨ Þß{p*< ÜÎÛÜ
îï$¼^j«£ :äÖ Õ& m=* "#%&' ÐÑ: "# X9*¤ j *
m
¥ k *m e
òóRt¦ { âÆ 3 k jmPXPXPX∑∑kmikmi∑jmijmijmijmii∈I∈iIi∈jmjmjm R==× 3 jmPXPXPXkmikmi∑kmikmi∑kmikmii∈km∈iI∈iIkmjm i X9j *m m= âÆ 4 k PX∑kmikmii∈Ijm EM= 4 jmPX∑kmikmii∈Ikm i I
I{||j
k*m
§^(:Fâ m= 6jjmkm $
Jm ó¨§^ j¥ e j òó x òøàs©Vj ã §^ê*m éW
: ª X9j *m þ m= âÆ 5 k PX∑jmijmii∈Ijm IM= 5 jmPX∑kmikmii∈Ijm27
Fâ þ m=9« 6>*j $
ó¨§^ j
¥
òó:Ôq x 6¬à á©Vþ m=às u1 p& §^(¾j *m éWã
:nè
§^Ní k Gh X§^(¾
ß k TFG7÷ip* Þß k : à ¨þ m={¼^j6$¼^îï6 ®4 ¯$ « m= âÆ 6 k IM=P× Xm 6 jmjjmωωjmijmipxjmijmi i P= X={||
¼^îï6$j6∏jm∏jmpxi∈Ii∈Irmirjmmijm °óωMN Ævk jmis−sjmikmilnS−lnSjmikmi ω= jmis−sjmikmi∑lns−lsni∈Ijmikmijm i s
s{||ÉiN§^
¥j K e
òók jmikmiPXPXjmijmikmikmi s= s=jmikmiPXPX∑jmijmi∑kmikmii∈Ii∈Ijmjm MNê
Æ 3 ?Æ 6 FG
± *i
m=
îïm=Kjm= u²³´Æ 7 ¨
òó{
m=
jm=K
îïm=: R=EX××P Q 7 jmjmjmjm
/
µ¶ ³´ *Õ&
°ót'e vJ e
îïK
j6k αααjmjmjmEX=EXP=PQ=Q()()()j∏j∏j∏ m∈Mm∈Mm∈M−j−j−j i α|É*m
¥j e
òó:jm ]< ó < $ !
« m=* "#%&' ÐÑ ÔÖfÓ·¸ $i ! lz
m= 1 *i
m=Gh *
m=:q *<FranKkeRlo s1e9 9lm 8 ^_` {|®~ jK m* e
m=
îïm=Kjm=*j $m ! lz
m=28
201 2 3
t¬ú L¹íº<lm lm m= BE I
lmîjmïm= $ BP I lmjm= BQ I äÖ{Q+m=* jmjm "#%&' ÐѺ= 2
Ʀ k EX+EXjmmj BEI= 8 jmEX+EXjmP+Pjmmj BPI= 9jm P+PjmQ+Qjmmj BQI= 1 0jmQ+Qjm Fâ ê
lm m= 6W ! lz m= 1j *m
m=hm *j
m= »J+ e
m= 1³´ *Õ&
°ót'eÖvJ e
m=:&r 6à ¹|V lm m= à :
¼Hod
rPicrkes c1o9t 9t109 9 7H-½P p ä hiÒÓ éGD{P¾õ#}¿b{K"# }¿b{ G"# }¿b{|É "#':BÀ1
À2 "# À ÁX Fâ 19Â6 9
29
201! 1ÃÄ $Å Æ "#p*WÇ[ $i KÅ s÷ ÆWÈp& "#' : 19Â91499K820Â02100x7r! y "# &'W:q| 199 M5 $ÉÊ
ËCÊÌ
Í
Î
Î ÏÊÌRª
"#%&'ÐVn:
M~ "# %&'| +r#+ p;' p;Ýp;às á|É "#%&'à:K C ÃbO $iÒÓ j¥J * ej 8 0ÑÒ Ó23&':"# ~H-½P p*1990—!+ 2011éGDôõPtN½ vJ+ "#' ÔÕ:i ¼Cerq
uMeiarar t2in0s 0 ^9 p;Æ 2 {|gv+ $ÒÓ ¼ p; â|1: "# äÞÖkå C× 1990?199! 3 $ÒÓ ¼ p;WÇ RWã ÖÝRp; Ws:q| 199 0 sã Rp;T <Ø1 $p
Å
Î ÏÊÌ
8s®
ËÙÊÌ
ÚÛ
&'Ü
Ý p;KÞß?àNWØ5 $á p; ©JØ ø:0x r# Rp;'F7 Ê@ * t çâ:7÷:1994?199!7 $ÒÓ p;sã:1998?200! 0 $ÒÓ p;»ãRäã µ¶ xF7$1997; åæÌçèé?3 X F:2001?200! 8 $ÒÓ 'ª ãWê±p; ë¿ ÖÝìír!õ©8 30
201 2 3
—
1990— 2 011 199 0199 1199 2199 3 19 94199 5199 6199 7199 8 19 9 920 0 0 . 161 .00 0 . 950 .990 .890 . 0 . 2 20..338 0 1 .22 . 919. 52 0 . 3 10..278 9 1 .81 . 608. 54 00 .501. 38 . 303. . 815. 17 1 . 2 00..063 0 0 .81 ! . 5 "# 0 . 5 5 9 $% . 913. 01 0 . 0 10..0289 & . 87. 39 0 . 6 ' ( . 90. 950 .970 .740 . ) 0 . 3 11..309 0 0 .20 * . 027. 93 0 . 1 00..269 4 0 .36 + . 306. 05 0 . 9 10..612 2 0 .21 , 0 . 9 7 0 20 01200 2200 3200 4 20 05200 6200 7200 8200 9 20 1 020 1 1 0..8908 0..98 980 .501. 900 . 06. 240 . 4 .00 .970 .83 50 .98 .980 .950 .92 60 .92 .890 .871 .00 90 .60 0..7876 0..79 0..991 0..79 .71 .000 .97 91 .00 ! .00 .840 .94 10 .45 "# 0..980 0..99 $% 0 . & 0..894 0..37 ' ( 960 .904. 920 . 02. 390 . 0 ) 0..8659 0..91 * .980 .820 .95 90 .89 + .00 .900 .77 50 .99 , 0..9757 01..00 --./#0123 45 6 78GD9:;P<= >?>@A2BCDEFG5 78GD9:;P< = >#HI+ JKL
MNOP >QRAht1tp// ta/31
E:xyr# *[ %öª r# &ru %öè]±c
;îr#:200 9 $ÒÓ© ãWRp; &r$ÒÓª ãp; xÒÓ 2007ï ðé?ñ ±cçèé?*© $ª ÐÑ Õ&GhÐÑ rò':÷:i ä íQC× $©hª
"# uã X ×Ø':Ã|Þ[ $ÉÊ
Î
Î ÏÊÌ
ËCÊÌ
Ä
Í Rª "#%&'TãWp; &rp;W : $p
'ós
8s®
Ý
ô
R© "#%&' 2000 ÇãWã Rp; 200 M0»õkp;:Fâ 1997Ìöçèé? ; * $Õ&ªÛÜ ! "#%&'ÐÑ3:Õ&: ÷øb{
j{Qb{ùú 1995—! 2 $ÒÓ0 0 9"#%&' ûÃWsb{ "#%&'Rp; Þ:
!"# |2ÕüW $ýÒÓ lm m= {| ©
! T UV + "W , XYZ [\] 01..042 199 5 [\ ^ 00..714 [\_` 11..334 [\] 01..136 200 0 [\ ^ 00..974 [\_` 01..080 [\] 81. 8 35. 9 546 .3421. 4 832 . 217 .3 2199 5 a2000[\ ^ 19. 9110. 8 39. 3 489 .5226. 2 119 .7636. 4 324 .6 0 9b [\_`14. 49. 5 6 25. 89 4 29. 74 19. 0 7 0 [\] 11..189 200 9 [\ ^ 11..053 [\_` 00..996 [\] 13. 07. 2 118 . 835 . 912 .9 0200 0 a2009[\ ^ 69. 8718. 4 8c29. 166 . 218 .9 3 9b [\_`c34. 19c16. 2 513. 9 412 . 4--d1 ef g[\ \hi gCDjklmGnoG 4CEPgIBIA C>QG?I>HummpKellsenAo2w0B0g \5hqrjst@CD u5v gwxqr\hA] \hy ^\hy_`\hBy5v u gwxqr\hz{ p |gwxqr\h >}~j 4t@A8ByA9ByA1B0CDF 5v g[\wx\hi A[\] \hi y[\ ^\hi y[\_`\hi BS 32
201 2 3
Å
p Ghª
Î
ËCÊÌ
ÉÊ
Í 23 X |':"# ä+m=C× lmîïm= 6øu èÖôõö uþ ß?RôõSlm m= ø
ôõW ÖÝ 1995—!20 00Gh2000—!2r!009y¾ TãW ôõSlmjm= øu
ôõö u q| 1995—! 20ÜÎ0ôõ0©J24 .:6 i äÕ& í|C× 0O 1995—!20 0 0 2000—! 20 0 $ª9
lm ôõö Vn < $©
ôõö S 1995—2000! $©
lmîïm= ôõ $ª
lmîïm= ôõR Ö2000—!20 09p9:Fâ $ lm m= GÔ íQ Õ&Ö3:Õ& Ö* $i "#%&'¼;Õ&ÐÑ x3 <
j{QttU:
$ % &' \] FranKkRelo s1e9 9A 8}ú éU@p 1 MCA }~ ojlm $ "#%&'; @p ^W$ íº OP@ â Æ 1 1k Cor=rβ+βB+βEI+βBPI+BQ+εI Control 1 1 ijt01ijt2ijt3ijtijtijt i p;Cor|rÉt i $ j ! "#%&' ij,tBE
IBP$IBQ{I||Ét $j lm
m=
lm
îijtijtijtïm= hlm
jm= :Ôq ê
OP@FG{|«
m=* "#%&' ÐÑ:Cald eCr t2e0in 06 7 ! ªÛÜÕ&uG7÷i "#%&' ×Ø ÔqOP ']Whçkjk Ó ª typ eóp*<© Ö $ª ! "#%&' ÓVn:Ãq [ ñ]Wihçkjk $ ¾ lnd i s ÓKt
cont in Óg23p& lan :g ( )*+ ùúW hi17ÒÓ ¬ x17
$ j¥J ej ¨Þ8 0 {|
á
Å
p
ô
s®Ì
ÚÛ
8s®
'ós
Ý
ÉÊ
&'Ü
ËCÊÌ
Ä
Í
Î
ËCÊÌ:J199 Ç5 $ÒÓ "#%&'ãWã Rp; Ý « m= W Ôq
j{Q:~X 1995—200933
! ¬25:5B<Î ÏÊÌ á½Õê± ÔÖ ³´á½ôõ
± "#%&'6¬ OPÆ ûÃW¬ Î ÏÊÌ W16 ¬24:0C h¬
'{Qâ|3:
Corr1 WDI PWT 7 .0 GDP 255 Corr2 UNCTA%& D stat 240 .876 BEI !"# $ CEP II 255 . 187 BPI !'( $ CEP BQI ! $ CEP II 255 lndist )*+,CE-PGIIrav .ity 255 conting /0 CE-PGIIrav .ity 255 lang 1 23CE-PGIIrav .ity 255 type 456 7 UN-8D945:;<<=>?6@ABCDE/0FGH1 23F I456 7JKcontFilnagnFgtypLMNe1KO PN0Q , (-. /012 Ã}~19Â92500 9$iÒÓ ¯°tOP = e<|4:|4 a OP:i OP1 3 "#%&'6 Co r~r+ 1éGDôõP¼Æ 2
±ÖvSOP4 6 "#%&'6 Co r~r+ 2á½ôõ¼Æ 2
±Öv:MNòW OP =fFG t
':OP1 4 ']Wlm m=
îïm=hjm= 6ækjSOP2 5 ']W $ @ ¾
ÓK
Óìa& «kjSOP3 6 ']W Ó <ª kj ó íQ* $ "#%&' ÐÑ: {Q|4:"# BOP1Fâ lm m= BE $lImjm= BQ Ino x©VBE$IBQàs I $i ! "#%&'à SBE,Iô'1 $i "#%&'áGô'7 SBQ,Iô' "#%&'áGô'3 :lmîïm= BP I Õno:i BOP2Fâ ']W $ @ ¾
ÓK
Óìa& «hçkjM BE
BIQ I&¬no ÖBP I BøõRø ÝÕnoSª×hçkj K
cont i nnog )@O # lm@ ¾ lnd isno $@O #p ìa& lan g RÝÕno ©ViÕ34
201 2 3
X "#%&' ;îÔñ:ª BOP3Fâ ']kj Óª
typ M eBE
BIQÎInoÝ BPnIoR tpyeno ©V $ª "#%&'Sihçkjklnd
iscont
ilnagnÓg ÕnoÓ $@O #p ©VÃÕ ÐÑ $i "#%&' ÒÓÔñ: MN{Q|4 OP1
2
3 =FG! BE$IBQÄI²no "#$ $ÒÓ ! lm m=$jm= GH ! "#%&'SBP IÕnoÝ Õ& OPÆ ;k ©ViÕ ! "#%&' ÐÑÔñShçkj íQ no H ! "#%&' Ölm ¾
K
a& ÕnoÝ 3k ©Vi* "#%&'3éð'ÐÑ:
Corr1 Corr2 1 2 3 4 5 6 *****************BEI 0. 4 17 3 4 6 8 9 7 8 3 3 3*********BPI 0 . 3 8 6 2 0 4 7 4 0 2 5 7 7*********BQI 0. 3 7 1 2 67 5 9 0 5 7 1**lndis 0 . 2 7 0 9 8 7 2 6************conting 3 2 5 3 2 1 4 8 1 7*********lang 5 8 1 8 00 6 2 4 9******type 8 4 19 76*****_cons 5 2 5 3 6 8 4 8 1 5 7 3N 255 255 255 240 240 240 2R 7 <<=>SHTUVWXYJZ[\]^Q_` ab>*****c* 35
uM Gá½%&'%GD%&'P ×OP4 6
= t ':Ó. lm m= $ íQ _èno x©Vlm m=$& ª
$ÒÓ "#%&' óÓÐÑÔñ lm m=às $i ! "#%&'à ÖÝ $ª "#%&'SBP
BIQGhiIhçkjÕnouÕ Õ ÐÑ $i "#%&' ÒÓÔñ: 3 Ú lm j
¼½¾
¿ÀÁ½ 7H ! "#%&': ÈÉ« m=* "#%&' æ~º= i@OK,-89ós: ®~ « m= {
Klm ^_` LWlm m= 6 ~19Â95200 9$ÒÓ lm {|
m=
îïm=$jm=* $i "#%&' ÐÑ:A =|Vklm m=* $ÒÓ ! "#%&'¼;no º» $ÒÓ "#% ' ÒÓ>7&' lmjm=
lmîïm=* "#%&'¼; º»Õno:A $ª
"#%&''Vn: A O[ . lm ÓãMN m=ÂÂÖÕ jm=$îïm= ô'é áG ! "#%&' Ö ,-çX ÷'$3º':Ôq 3>*< ¢B ,- çX ¦( ½
)X$
H ½
¼^Ní ô' 6G ! "#%&':
Ká*+, ÒÓ ,- çXK%.fÓ-8Ji $ "#%&' xSq': ,3456 1 . F D I
!"#$ J .
20 19!0. 2 %& '() *+,. -./
!01$2234 5OEC 678D J . 9:
20 11!1. 3 ;(< =+>. 4? @AB
!"#$CDE J . FG 20 05!4. 4 HIJ KL. 4 MNOPCQRS TUVWXY J .
20 11!0. 5 Z[\ 4 MNOPC]RS J .
I^_ 20 190 4!. 6 `a. ABbc ABde
!"#$22f4 TUghAB Cij J . 936
201 2 3
:
kl 20 01!9. 7 Ariel B uCrshtreiisntopher Kurz an dP Lroindduac tTioe nsa Ta trhianed geInterna-tional Transmission oJ .f JBousrinnaels so fC Mycolne set2a0r 0y58 E 54!c onomics775—95. 8 Bac kDus. K P. . J. K eahnode F. Kydland. Interna tTiohneaolr yB Eesvsi -Cyclesden Cc e. in T. F. Cedo .o Flreoyntiers of Busine sPs rCinyccelteo nR Uesneiavrecrhsity Pre s1s995. 9 Ber gPin. and C.-Y. Lin. The Dynamic Eff eR Ns oBfE CRu rWreonrcky- Union on Tradeing Pape rsN 1a6ti2o5n9al Bureau of EIcnoc o0m10ic. R esearch 1 0 César C aAldlebreórnto CEhrnoensgto Stein. Trade Intensity and BusinessCycle Synchroniza-tio nAre Developing Cou nJ Jieosu ranayl Dofi fIfnetrernnta ?t2i0o 0n7al EconomicsVolum Ies s7u1 e8 12—21. 1 1 Cla rTk. E. a nvda En . Wincoop. Borders J a. nJdo uBrnuasiln oefs sI nCteyrcnlaetsional Econo m20ic 0s51 559—85. 1 2 Fidr mJu. cThe Endogeneity of the Op tiImnturma- iCnduur rsetarnycd yT rAadrea CriteriaEMU Enl aR BemOeFnITt Disc u2s0si 0o81n. P apers 1 3 Fran kJe. lA. and RAo. sKe.. The Endogeneity of the O Jp .t imum Currency Area CriteriaEconomi c1 J9o 9u18r0n 8a1l009—25. 1 4 Gru bKeno oMillis. How Much Does International Trade Affect Business Cycle Synchroniza-tio nR . Manuscript Federal Reserv e2 of Dallas. November 1 5 Hum mD elasnd P Klenow. The Variety and J .Q Auamlietryi coafn a E Ncoa-tion’s Exportsnomic R 2e0v 0ie95w 53! 704—723. 1 6 J.-S. Pe ePo Reaoundeau. Extensive Margin of Trade and Business Cycle Correl aR oCnRsEM CNRS 6211-U 2n0iv1e0r. s ity of Rennes 1 1 7 Kindle bCer. Foreign Trade and M t h. eN Newat i HoYnavalle nE Uconnivoemrsyity Pre s1s962. 1 8 Ko sMe. A. and K. Yi. Internation aIl sT Vraedrtei caanld I nBteugsirnaetisosn C thyec lMesiss-ing L J Akmerican Eco n2o0m 091ic 15 !R 3e7v1ie—w75. 1 9 Ko sMe. A. & K-M. Yi. Can the Standard International Business Cycle Model eExplain the Rela-tion between Trade aJ n. dJo Cuornmaol voef mInetnetr?n at2i0o 0n6a l82 !E conomics2627 95. 2 0 McKi nI. Optimum C J u. rAremnceyri cAanre aEsco n1o9m 653ic 34 !R eview71272 5. 2 1 Mel tzAelrlan H. Monetary and Other Explanat iJo .n Jso oufr -the Start of the Great Depression37
nal of Moneta r1y9 E 7cN6oonvoem m4icb5se5r—71. 2 2 Sh inK. and YW. aJn. g. Trade Integration and B uthsein Cesass eC oyfc le Co-movementsKorea with Other J A. Jsaiapna nC aonudn ttrhie sW 2o0r 0l1d4 6 E2c1o3n—om30y.
’
Liu En zLhiuua nL ijun Tianjin University of FTinianjcien &3C0 E0h2i!c no2an2omics T h e paper analyzes st hoef etrfafedcet onf mbuasrignienss cycle synchroniza-tion theoretically and fluirztehde rf adcetsc orifb tehse t hbeu ssitnyess cycle synchroniza-tion and bilateral marginsa owf iethx pitosr etm tparajrodtren etorraf bdCahseid on thebilateral trade d2a0t0a9 o. fA 1t9 l9a0st tuhpe ap arpeegr essestiso n model includingmargins of trade and ot hemerp ciorinctarlolly vaanraialybzles thoe relationship between margins of trade and buastiinoens sa ncdy cflien dsys ntchhart otnhiez bilateral extensivemargins of trade has ponsciteiv oen a tnhde rboubsuisnte sins fcluyecle China’s business cy cwleit his imts odreev seylonpcihnrgo npiazretdners then its devel-oped par tners. ! B i"la teral Mar gBinuss ionfe Ts srS aCydyneclhero nization# $
% k &F'1& 3mn o m np& ( .÷ #/01RÂ23+4s ó 56&Â678
9K:;b(9*ç<È Â=E = Ï?ç rY>?ù@·Oê0 =çè AL0 12YJA7 9BC00 i29 D¬zE F6#D$FGHIJ KLMKF º»kBN «xydeA O: 38
