!" #$%&'()*+,-./01234$
56)*789 #$:;<)*=>?@7,-ABCD?EF
5G H)*7IJKL$M&'NOPQR+G STUVNalbantian, 2004WCXNYZ[:\.Kaplan & NortonV1991W]^)*&' NO?_7`a$bc d!" 5efgh$ijkl imnoKl i p+0qld&/ #efrRstu$ m .vwxV2004WyzXNYZ[+{| 5}<~
5 5+ 5^)*i p+0qlefg
5C 7 + d
5$yz +:;)*,-AB+})*QRC . 2+
5$
5 KL )* ¡d+2¢.£¤$5 ¥¦§¨
5 2C ©ªV2001W«H ¬® ¯°$ ±²7³1´µ$¶· ¸¹º»³²$¼ ³½7$H¾¿´µ¹º»³À$ÁhÂÃÄV2002W§Å«HƧÇÈ
È ÉLg $¯°Ê È +È ÉLË°ÌÍ$«HÎ;*ÏÐÑÒÓV2000W ¯ 1
°$ ÔÏг²CÕÖ ¯°$ Ô×Ø»+ÉLA ½$Ù m Ú+·^ÛÉLg$ÜÝ«H +2¢.¦·7Þ ?$ßÁ +2g^5 àg§C áâV2002WãäåICæY#*^ ç5$èéêR+ëfQRìí $¯°ICæY#* =+êQîRïðËñòÌ$óhôõöV2004W«HÎ;*${| 5+XNYZ[» ¯° efgiîRSTUlÛ p+0qefgi²d ï÷lËñòÌCãøuLùú =HøuLIJ$ôûüV2001WHýþ"#* ¯° =V ãÕW7 .$ øuL²² V WÛã 7 .C ÕÖ $ KLg
»&
$ «H
§#*$ #*ìí»$ KL+2g$Á^5 Æ àC V2003Wã * 3^÷$ ¯°i »lH # } ® KL # : U Àd 1ñòÌfIJ$Áh«H?!#*v"|V2001W ¯°È *H
#$7G KL²P%#*$óh &'V1995W( !) ¯° G¤ y*Û +,-/±.$2/°±0C 7
»1ÕÖ s23$( O4¦§¨ :;gG ST$^5 à5C
67
8Y
YZ[+XNYZ[H
5 ¯°$9:8Y¥
5G ;i^¡ l<=G i05l$&'>?PG i@Al+BùiQRl$
5QR
´
57»$ C + *DEãÛF GHdVNalbantian, 2004WC( 2
§¸IZJ&'KL
5gÉf$Mi¸ðlßNOPQ¤ OVNalbantian, 2004W$¼RSTV2003W( !D ¯°$UV#*{| 5G <=_êWÕXY¸ðZìCÁh [
\]G¤gh$^[¸ðã+, 2*$÷LakerV1990Wãi¸ðßNl imKLl¢ef>? +,$ãÛ_`aV2005W«Häåb3
5 $¯° G +2 ¯ ð 1cd»$M5 e C f$gJ
5+2gC 5 h
i7~
5
» + ¡dH)* 2gIJ$e äåDjêWÕê®^ ç5$klm +
54$ãG STU7nLNO
5H2gIJC o
5VHuman CapitalWpqC
´7 $Ðrs7 tshSchultzV1960WY“G
5VInvestment in Human CapitalWӤ i
5lVHuman CapitalWuvw}<Þ$
5xyqC}^
5 7Ø{~
5^)* # [g
N$]^
5^)* #g§$|1 + G
5$¼)*
5NIJ_)*G STUC
5 5VCapitalW }bVLandWY #~ÕÁð 1UKLg»$17 7$
50^67
xy$NalbantianV2004W]^qC h
® ( Y p}6 C NalbantianV2004W]^
5 1¢5/Éil+i®1l$ilu 17+ ?H° h1 $HB 3
ùsh1QRi®1luQR
§®$ò C+ =¼0q$IM6HG Å #7àe 1QRCBrookingV1996W]^
5^ # 8 É»$+ÜÝg #$ÁhDess & Picken(1999)¥
5Ø^$&'+Zg ÛCz $ãÛKL 7 $!¸)*7QR Û $? ¡® 1VEdvinsson & Malone, 1997WC DavenportV1999W]^
5¢£1¤
N0~ VabilityW ·V^behaviorW
¥ VeffortW
G¤¸ð(time¦CDzinkowskiV2000W]^
5+m
7 (capabilities) (skills)ãÛ *(expertise)dCBrooking(1996)¥7
5Z§^¨~ VeducationW *DE ©(vocational qualifications) (work related knowledge) *7>Q+ ª(occupational assessments and psychometrics) # (work related competencies)C .H
5Ø{Õ«1Pbc$¬" gã *d^
5h$ÕÖ
5
N%Ô®¼¡)*$ ]^
5yz»G ^)*:;QRC .67
8Y VHuman Resource AccountingW {| 5
YZ[ XNYZ[ ¬z»¯d?!nLNO
5$67 (Labor Economics)ã7 7GH$ZJ
$7 SchultzV1960W]^
5M6¥7
° # $±² # ³G¤¸+
5G KL = * d7IJCBeckerV1964W]^´" # µ^g
5C
57
Ȧ&
$Ù¥
51Oxy,^Ox 4
y$\1960$HermansonY1964§· S¸ < S/m ¤
4 f$¹S/mºr^»¬$( S/H .+G
r1 ¼$·S¸½¯8YH
57tuC
8Y¥i # Bù@Ag
G 2¾l¿ã 5 ^i #¼ l$ÀÁGV1991W]^
8Y YÂ 9: ¹ ÃÄ$|1
ÅÆ)*H
7;$ÇÈ9:8Y7?ÉC 9: 2&'»¬FÊ2$ßÁ{| 5Ë ;$DzinkowskiV2000WÌ4SMAC $}< {| 5NO¯P
5>?¯^~®YÍ
ήgÏÐ _ Bø¢ ¦
ï÷ øuL }< eÑw!²e·gï÷ ÒÓ:;7Ô QR Ò§ÕÖ :;gÔ QRCSveiby(1999)¥)*&/ #Z^5 ¨~× mYye +hnye$× ~ *
7 (YØ # ¼ Ë°# FÙG'7
)$mYye~ÚÛ Ü y ¢H ÝÞ ß:Û d$hnyeàÚÛjkÛá âðg ã ⯠®µÐÛ/ä$ã0q/ 2U ×Ø»>?&/ #NO$i× lNO¯ /V/2-1W~ /2-1 × NO ¯» × 1 *
7 ´ 2 *
Xå 0q/ 3 *
Xå (³ æ ) 4 05ç´è@éï÷ 5 XåÒÓ *
ݳ gê 5
6 H *
e ëZìL 7 ¤7 *
ç 7 *
ï÷ 1 *
ç´
ï÷ 2U 2 íî2* 3 *
XåÔ QR 1 XåÊ 2 *
×Ø» 3 HÖ ïð 4 *
íU ó§ñ .(
YZ[VHuman Resource ScorecardWù>?
5$UlrichV2001W}<òó» # Iúô
$ãi2Ul+iG l7nLNO
5$2U»7NO¯ÚÛ~õ 2<çÖ ´é7ïU ÒÓ7Ö 05
ß:0ö¦¤7÷Zï Ò §Ó
705 Xå ¡ ÒÓ7
`¡ C
5G 7¯1~Xå Òøù ú7 û
Xå ê ³ï÷ãÛ ¡ çÖ ´é7ï÷dC Kaplan & Norton7XNYZ[bc2ßü$¼MayoV2001WãøuL ý U # ùNO $ ]^ Vemployee capabilitiesW þ2C ã ¬z»>?¯nL<¯$GrossmanV2000W]^
5>?¯OP z~2U»VefficiencyW òó»Vstrategic metricsW G STUVROIW #* »Vall-industry indicatorsWd¤ xy$Ì4ÕÖ¤ xy»¯Grossman}<NO
5 ¯~ 1 @¤ßNVrevenue factorW 2 ´ U(voluntary separation rate) 6
3
5Ô QRVhuman capital value addedW 4
5G STUVhuman capital ROIW 5 ´ÖT @¤÷ZïVtotal compensation revenue percentW 6 ´605 @¤÷ZïVtotal labor cost revenue percentW 7 G ßNVtraining investment factorW 8 Ò §
g05Vcost per hireW 9 Ò
05Vhealth care costs per employeeW 10
í05Vturnover costsW Ì4ÕÖ . g¯$5
e
5NO¯ ~ 1 Xå ~* ³²$/®
5×س²$³ $Ù OPÏ Ö³²gÖ 05C 2 ~ ²/ p b$Ù
`05³²$?!¨£#*[ ?!C 3 ¡~H
5ÜÝG $/)*H
5;KLC !" Miler(1990)ãG STU G 7° oO êWç1U ç1U×Ø» # Ô QRÛ # d>O2CDelaney Huselid(1996)ã# È # È 7m¯ ½
#7 jkøuL .+g ð è*é0qU êWç1U U · dù>?2CNkomoV1987Wã 2¯~ 0qU è@0qU AU #STU$+
¯~Ò
Xå U Ò
XåÖ #é$¬z +
¢ef>?2CHuselid, Jackson, & SchulerV1997Wã # Tobin’s q #STU^2¯CÌ4ÕÖ . $5 e i # l ^2NO¯ðC 7
Knight(1999)]^})*7êWQRVmarket valueW¤
NZ ^~
5 ye 5 hY 5ãÛ 2$]^G
5 ¹sr1 7¯ 5$ßÁ½ r1 # ghY 5Vproductive external capitalW$y*¥ sr07 2 ¯°
5 02 .7®$P /° 0VFitz-Enz,1997W$80%7)*QRù´)*7
5VGrossman,2000Becker & Huselid,2001W$(
^$|1
5:;)*QRSveibyV1999W]^g7¸$)*7&/ #ÙØ ®7èéêQèéîRY] ^)*!" 5$&'<=&/ #$IchniowskiV1990WãièéêRîRïlVTobin’s qW ^2¯ zÕÖ .ú'$e iTobin’s ql^ 2g
NOC GrossmanV2000W
5G STU¯$bc
5G §Õ :;7@AHatchV2005W]^
5G STUVHuman Capital ROIW$^>?)* qC2/°g .¯$}<
5G STU>?¢H$V! "W$5 e ¯^2 C −(
−( + )) + "2-1
5G STU Ì4 .H)*
5+ 2g $5
e # 2>?¯~ 1 Tobin’s q~)*&/ #:;)*QRg C 2 # ~
5:;Ô QRg C 3 Human Capital ROI~ã IùNO
5C BeckerV1964W]^ Ô .P³ $ ³0$¼Abraham & FarberV1987WÌ4i °$ ÞlVJob Match TheoryWh% >.H ½$ # ³²$SveibyV1999W]^
<=0×Ø»$rI 8
J_+ &'»C m + (Í $)*GV2003W¯°È 10ãÕ7$P øɳ²$óh+,ÓV1999W ¯°)* -zL+ Ë°Ì$Ì4ÕÖ .H gÞ$5 }<.æ§~ H1~Xå +21ñòÌÍ/ MincerV1974WYP ¯° ³².P # ³²$ ^0ù³²7@A$Lockheed, Jamison & LauV1980W«H1' # f ¯°$ݳ¤ 2 $ ¹#OÒ $óh$BishopV1994W7 ¯°$ ã} CBlack & LynchV1996W«HÎ;*+¡Î;* ¯°$ ñòIJ # C m§Å«HÎ;*{| 5 Vôõö, 2004W¯°)*iî #STUl+i²d ï÷lË°Ì$ zÕÖ .ú'ñ4 +2ðË°ÌÍ$M5 }<.æ ~ H2~Xå +21ñòÌÍ/ ôõöV2004WãèéêR+îRïVTobin’s qWNO{| 5$¯°
5N5²d ï÷+{| 5:;+&'66$¼Bouillon, Doran, and OrazemV1996W7 ¯°® Ø»
57G ¡Û d$H®êWQR 1ÌÍ72AC m 7TV1997W¯° H +¡ ¯1ñòÌÍIJ$ÕÖ ñ4G ^0ùÌf@A$ßÁ5 }<Æ5.æ~ H3~ ¡+21ñòÌÍ/ #$ 5Áã5 g 8e e ZJ ^hCƧ9 :Ö5 g 8e+ .æÆ 9 ;<ç5=>GHÆ59 9
$;<5 ¹ g:YZJ C %& '( Ì4 ?j+ mh $«H)*
5æÅG¤¯~Xå Xå Ò
¡$+)* 2¯~èéêR+îRïVTobin’s qW Ò
è@
5G STUVHC-ROIW$«H
5G ¯+)*è2¦· $5 8e "~ + !"+ #*RTobin’s q Xå RÒ
è@R R
5G S ¡RTUR Ì4 @A+ $5 }<.æ ~ H1~Xå +21ñòÌÍ/ H2~Xå +21ñòÌÍ/ H3~ ¡+21ñòÌÍ/ )* )*è2NO¯$®èQ^ 5êWH)*è2$8ÜÝg ¯$5 ®èéêR+èéîRg$ã®i èlÒèêR+îRgï^¯7$>Bäåèél êWm¯·gèé^ ç5$³C¸ð+05$!¸ Oç5/»e DåDjEF Då50VGHDå50$TSEC Taiwan 50 indexW$1DåDjEF +I ¸1C®Vã GHFTSEWJ!z $=>l êW 1/»g502èé Kμ0$LM ³NèéQ©7$µ /ODåèéêWg¬"2$¦¼}áó§G
P+DåêW¬"/°g C5 e 94Æ5Qgäå500Zè^ ç5C5 10
5G qC2 $ fklCð^1999"2004èê $´Y300Sç5)*L $h
fù
ÚÛm TVTEJW äåDjEF äå500Z®gS+ S¸C ,- § ´ÅVIndependent VariableW Xå Xå Ò
¡ #*^´ÅC 1 Xå ~ e «ç5®S$ U4g*
Xå R/C 2 Xå³ ~ ãç5®M ´V² ã ã9Y] ² ã12Y] ã15Y] V&ã18Y] W&ã22Y]WXYã´
$Y]<ç5®XåM $/ç5®Xå C 3 Ò
¡~ ãç5® S¸Z#4g ¡ YãS U4g®
$Y]<Ò
¡C 4 #* äå500Z)*$ù´?!#*$M5 Y>?
5+2¸$ò?!#*ðgï³C [ÅVDependent VariableW 5 ãèéêR+îRïVTobin’s qW Ò
è@
5G STU^[ÅC 1 èéêR+îRïVTobin’s qW ãç5®S®x\] #4gLÒèêRYãîR$Y]<èéêR/îRïRVTobin’s qWC 2 Ò
è@ 11
S/^A/#4giè@îél/ç5® _# }áÈ # 7`aQR$Ò
è@ /^ :;gQR$Y]GH^~è*îéYã´
C 3
5G STUVHuman Capital ROIW
5G # gC
5G STUNOG §Õ7
52< ã:;<N b$ b^@AcY¡
G 2<$Y]H ~ −(
−( + )) +5 ãiè@îél/@A$Ö +õ 0541ç5®g S/ ds$Y]ç5®g
5G STUC . /0 5 ´Å~Xå Xå Ò
¡ #*C[Å~èéêR+îRïVTobin’s qW Ò
è@
5G STUCã1999~2004Õê® fZJç5$¹ ãÛ:Ye"$
¼ fg¨hi+g¨ZJÕ
D.æÕCã «HF _g:YG'¦·;<~ 1 jÖ:YZJ~ EF 5k f» Zl-\C 2 m¨ ¸ðn#ZJVPooled Cross-Sectional Time-SeriesW ã:Ye"SHAZAM$¼ ?!Cç5g$|1:Ye"$MqC¼o$
5G +2gC . 12 3 456 12
5 ãäå500Zè^ ç5$59«Hç5®5 f¦·g¨jÖ:YZJC § äå500® Ì4äåDjEF 94Æ5Q¯lgäå500Zè$ =><7)*!p /V/4-1W /4-1 äå500® q rH q rH q rH q rH q rH 1301 ä s 2317 ` t 2408 u 2880 vu 2892 Ƨ 1303 u w 2324 a x 2409 y z 2881 { 3009 |}Ý 1326 ä 2325 ~ 2412 vݵ 2882 3012 1402 2330 ä'Ý 2454 / ¯ 2883 m¯ 3045 äå 2002 ¬ 2344 v{Ý 2475 v = 2884
4904 9ݵ 2201 2352 < 2498 zÝ 2886 5854 z 2301 x 2353 2603 q 2887 ä 6004 ÕD 2303 / Ý 2354 `ð 2609 <tF 2888 6116 2308 äzÝ 2357 v V 2610 v 2890 v 6505 äs 2311 2382 z 2801 O 2891 µ 9904 x 0 0)*Zs ¬ Ýü F d #*$P ãs*$4 ç8%*$1 ç2%¬*$1 ç2%*$1 ç2%Ýü*$25 ç50%F*$3 ç6% *$14 çV28%WÎ*$1 ç2%$ Zl-/ /V/4-2W /4-2 ç5#*Zl 78 9- :5; <= 4 8% 13
> 1 2% ?@ 1 2% AB 1 2% CD 25 50% EF 3 6% GH 14 28% IJ 1 2% gg¨:YZJ «H1999~2004
5G +G STXå$EFç5® fgx\C ^~gðÒ
M $/Xå³ ¸ð^~gðÒ
¡^ äa1,735~3,600gðTobin’s q³_èéêW+ ¡IJ$¢ùË° £B$1999ïð_2004Ò
è@ $¤0q19918,000V¥ÕW0q_200485,000V¥ÕW
5G STU2001g9¤ $G STU^ÕÕW$Lç5jÖ:Y4!p /V/4-3W /4-3 5 f¦Ö:Y KL 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 K 5M N OPK- N QRST Tobin's q N YZ[\ 14
HC-ROI 1XåF³§¨RIJM5 ©ãç5 Ó$bH
5gEF$ ^~Ò
M $³_ ÛãÛ²d ª«$ ïXÕÕ ¡^ÕW~ÕWgðTobin’s q^~ðÒ
è@Ë°¤Õ £B$¥ÕWÕ¥ÕW
5G STU20019Ë°Õ£B$ÕW0q"ÕW$Lç5 Ó!p /V/4-4W /4-4 5 f Ó KL 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 K 5M N OPK- N QRST Tobin's q N YZ[\ HC-ROI ) !"]^_ äå500Zè$0)*ùY?!#*$59¥:Ö?!#*
5G +)*2g$( ¢¬V1999~2004Wç5® f$gJ?!#*
5G ~ § Xå H2gIJ Xå HÒ
è@8 IJ $Y*Ë°Í 15
gh$P%#*Xå Ò §% }è@ $}®L8 ^ *$Ò § ã^:;153,000V¥ÕWgè@CXå H
5G STUVHC-ROIW Ë°ÌÍ$ *Xå § ãH}
5G ÕCXå HTobin’s qIJ?ñò$Xå HHC-ROIIJ ³^¯°$Ýü *^ñòÌÍC Xå HÒ
è@Y*gh$P #*%Ë°ñòÌÍXå HHC-ROI$ 1#*%Ë°ÌÍñòV!p/4-5WC /4-5 1999~2004Xå H2gIJ a/N UVHC-ROI 78 `YZ[\ Y[\ <= * > ?@ ** AB ** CD ** * EF ** GH ** IJ ** R-Square ±~ **/4p².01*/4p².05 H2gIJ H
5G STUVHC-ROIWIJ8^ñò$*G Õ^
5G STU8²g#*C 16
HTobin’s q Ë°ÌÍIJ$F*^ÍÒ
è@³_ IJgKL$ã Ýü F³^ñò$Ù+¬*Ë°ÍC s Ýü+ *Xå HTobin’s q Ò
è@ HC-ROI%Ë°ÌÍCÝü*Xå HTobin’s q Ò
è@ HC-ROI%Ë°ñòÌÍCs*YXå HTobin’s q HC-ROIË°ÌÍñòCV!p/4-6W /4-6 1999~2004 H2gIJ Tobin's q a/N UV HC-ROI 78 `Y100b\ YZ[\ Y[\ <= ** * > * ?@ ** AB ** CD ** 19133** ** EF 13564** GH 92549* IJ * R-square ±~ **/4p².01*/4p².05 5 Ò
¡ Ò
¡HÒ
è@IJ8^ñò$?Þ #*%^ÌÍ$ã * G H*Ò
è@IJ 8 z99715V¥ÕW$Ò
¡H
5G STUVHC-ROIW$1nZ® fU³?É$«H¶ s f¦·ZJ$¯°s ¬+*$ 17
¡H
5STUåË°ÌÍ ¡+Tobin’s qg$Y*Ë°Íh$)*G HTobin’s q%Ë°ñòÌÍC s +¬*Ò
¡HHTobin’s q Ò
è@ HC-ROI%Ë°ÌÍCÝü F +Î*Ò
¡HHTobin’s q+Ò
è@Ë°ÌÍV!p/4-7WC /4-7 1999~2004 ¡H2gIJ Tobin's q a/N UV HC-ROI 78 `Y100b\ YZ[\ Y[\ <= ** ** > * * ?@ ** ** AB ** CD ** ** - EF ** ** - GH ** ** - IJ * - R-square ±~ **/4p².01*/4p².05 c 1 ´Þ fkl+ZJg9$5Á«H y*¦·$Ƨ9«H y*g$Æ 9;<5 ! Õ uÆ59Þ5 XYg Cì+9µ GÍC 1 18
5
5+ 2g$ ã g¨y*~ § Xå H
5G STUVHC-ROIWIJ³^ñò$Y#*ï³ ã *8^ñò$¶·ZJy*ñ4Xå Ò 1$ }
5G STUÕ$Pv^Ýü*ÕC HèéêR+îRïVTobin’s qW
5G STUVHC-ROIW¢[Å7IJ³^<ñCãTobin’s q¼o$Ýü*7IJ8^ñò$³ § ã}Tobin’s qz190%CÁh$ HHC-ROIgIJ$ã *IJ8^ñò$ݳ§ $ ã}ÕC 5 ¡ ¡HÒ
è@
5G STUVHC-ROIW³ IJ C ¡HÒ
è@}ã *8^ñò$®Ò §
Ó ¡2< ã}Ò
è@99,715V¥ÕWC ¡HHC-ROIIJã*8^<ñ$ÒG §
Ó ¡$H}ÕC ¬"¼o$Ýü+ ¢ #*$
5G H 2IJ8 C j¸®PricewaterhouseCoopers/SaratogaV2003W«H} )*¦·§Å
5ci¯°~Ò
è@ Ó^äa10,500V¥ÕW} 312,738Õ
5G STU Ó^äa49Õ1} .48}ÕCï³5 ç5)*$ç5)*YÒ
è@ s ¬ Ýü+F#*A} )*$
5G STU *A} $ñ4 m)*Y}
5G STUÕ¹1?Ég¼V!p/5-1WC /5-1 ç5®Ò
è@+HC-ROI Ó 19
#* s ¬ Ýü F Î Ò
è@ V¥ÕW VÕW defg )*6 )*H6 7G ãÛºVG @A ® (
'» P
5$ G
ÕÖ5
5 VNalbantin$2004W$HatchV2005W]^vs¼ ¥tu ½Y>?
+ ¾ g
5¯Õ$¿ ¯°)*
57À ã^)*:;QR$5 ã ?!fÍ:Ö! Õg u~ § ~ 6 + 5Ál£#*$!" 5+
5 1U»$Ál£#*Â$
5»³À$( pÃÇ ÃÇ&'
5$0ù7
Ó05 À+ # }$¦¼},-AB$Ì4±²STcÄ'à$ =_zU§KL9$ # <°ÅÆÇ" Àg°äC!¸ $ÈÉ ÛP%ʾ $ À<=6 ×ØLì$)*
2<øùû> dBO CM)*˳ÃÇ0ù@A!¸$ [t05ÌìÍ G STU§ C YÁl£#*Ýü#*$5k³ ïXH)*QR1ÜÝ/$!¸ ³ /
@ g p $Y ?HH76êW $ =Y6êW79àìr <ñ$ÎÏ¢ù²d ª«$ 20
Ù ïXY)*>#Õ¹ 12 $º ¡ÐÑÒiÍ ² =$¼6¸Y6êWÕ$ p 7
»$)* ¡
Ó¼6
ÓÔ9/7 p C 5 9:8YÕॠ¡;^ ¡ g§n$Ï ¡H)* +QR%1ñòb$ ;^)* #+ÖG $ «H +,2*IJßN$ /H h ÉL º d$ +,*!¸Í×G Y 7¡$ :;gG STC
1C$Í G STU§ ^ »G
7J!i¯$)*G
5 Á$ ¡ #* ¡Ø68
7G $ãF+ *¼o Ô
7QR² G 0ù72*$)* Omn6êW+hn#*ÙÚ$ÙØG ÅiC hi jk lm 5 ãäå50^ ¯7$15kg Cì$59 Cì!¸H9µ }< ·g ~ § f» 5 ( vÛ fkl$H
5¿NO&'ds$øuL *
ï÷ Ud f$«HÁÅ 9µ .$ ãe·gÛ fkl~¸Ü'$°z5 gvÛ fkl$¹ZJr »¬»C ç5 äå50 => /»®$Y)*Ý¢^ £)*$H £)*7
5ZJà 1BÞ$ 9µ . ã DC8 =>giäå £100l0Z)*¦·ZJ$EF+ï³ £)*+ £)*
5x\C 5 21
5 _#*ð
5ìí$Ù
5+2gð XYP%ßN$ 9µ ¤ 5ÁlL
dÌìÅ$ãPrßàË°
5+2gC ¤ G' 5 e G
¶·´Þð$ð?É$ðH
»+ðEá G
¶·ZJ$.ØË°Ç»$âóð XY7¡Ç»$M9µ ( °1¸ðn#¢£^ yzã~Õ¶·¢£+¡Ç»¢£
5+2gC § ¸ðZ9Vtime lagW2* 5 e ¸ðn#¢£$
5+ 2g$äÌ]C fH´ÞgÚå$ 9µ ã¸ðn#¢£ dæ f CðC no 1. v"|$2001C
$ç ~
V&Þ 2. vèÄ$2000C
! "#$% &'( )*$äé~ ê 8Y ßV&Þ C 3. ëìâ$2005C#+,-./0 12 $ # C 4. íîï$2003C 3
45"#'( )*$ç ~
V&Þ C 5. üð$2003C 678 -.
: ;! $äu~q è V&Þ C 6. 0ñ$2005C<= >?@ABC5! -#DEF<= )*$äé~ äå Û * V&Þ C 22
7. áâ$200òC
JK ! LMN#ICOP
)*$äé~ Då 8Y V&Þ C 8. ©ª$200óC+,-. QIR >ST:
QU45 ;! "#DV<W)*$²ô~
V&Þ C 9. &'$199õC?@ABXY 9Z[
\=] 45 !\^ "#_ `ISO 9000 abcde^fgh )*$²ô~
V&Þ C 10. $200öCEij
kl?@
mnoQUpq! r LM"# sitQ uv)*$²ô~
V&Þ C 11. )*G$200öCQUwx
>Qyz{| ;! $äé~ äå÷à * V&Þ C 12. øùú(Karl Erik Sveiby Õò)$1999C}~
["
C f $äé~û{ C 13. ÂÃÄ$200òC
>Q=! r -# )*$ç ~ Õ )* V&Þ C 14. ÑÒÓ$200üCp8qr p8 s a/tuvw xy]z{ |}~I8$äu~ 0ö )* ßV&Þ C 15. % ý$2001C
45! $²ô~
V&Þ C 16. þ $1995C1995 ─¡¢£¤t¥¦$ $312C 17. ÀÁG$1991C 9§P
&-.!¨©$äé~ßv "Z C 18. 7 $2004C ª
45! r$ç ~
V&Þ C 19. 7ÌXdúVRobert S. Kaplan, David P. NortonÕòW$200 C[«¬ 23
®r [¯~C°±²\³f´µ$äé~ < C 20. 7T$199 C 9-.
45! ;" ¶·¸ f¹º$²ô~
V&Þ C 21. _`a$2004C 3»
45! r-¼
!½¾ $ç ~
V&Þ C 22. R& $2003C ¿ ÀÁ
ÂÃÄ ! r LM"#ÅÆÇÈÇÉ<W)*$äé~ äå 8YßV&Þ C 23. RST$2003C 12 !\Ê $ä ~
t )* ßV&Þ C 24. +,Ó$1999$ ËÌÍY
Îz{|! "#D%ÏÐ<W)*$²ô~
)* ßV&Þ C 25. ôûü$200óCQU Ñ Ò
QUwÓ! ;-#ÔÕ¤ )*$ç ~ )* ßV&Þ C 26. ôõö$200 C12
Ö×PØ ! "#ÅÆgh )*$äu~ 0ö 8Y ßV&Þ C 27. Abraham, K. & Farber, H. ,1987. Job Duration, Seniority and Earnings, American Economic Review, 77(4 278-297. 28. Becker, B. E., Husield, M. A., and Ulrich, D., 2001. The HR ScorecardLinking People, Strategy, and Performance, Boston~Harvard Business School Press. 29. Becker, G. S., 1964. Human Capital: A Theoretical and Empirical Analysis with Special Reference to Education, Chicago, IL: NBER, University of Chicago Press. 30. Bouillon, M. L., Doran B. M., and Orazem P. F., 1996. Human Capital Investment Effects on Firm Returns, Journal of Applied Business Research, 12, 1~30-41. 24
31. Black, S. E., and Lynch, L. M., 1996. Human Capital Investments and Productivity, Technology, Human Capital, and The Wage Structure, 86, 2~263-267. 32. Bouillon, M. L., Doran B. M., and Orazem P. F., 1996. Human Capital Investment Effects on Firm Returns, Journal of Applied Business Research, 12, 1~30-41. 33. Brooking, A., 1996. Intellectual capital. London: International Thomson Business Press. 34. Davenport, T. O., 1999. Human Capital: What Is It and Why People Invest It . SF: Jossey- Bass. 35. Dess, G. G. & Picken, J. C.,1999. Creating Competitive (Dis)advantage: Learning from Food Lion’s Freefall, Academy of Management Executive, 13(3 97-111. 36. Delaney, ., & Huselid, ., 1996. The impact of human resource managemenet practices on perceptions of organizational performance, Academy of Management Journal, 40(1¦~88-171. 37. Dzinkowski, R., 2000. The Measurement and Management of Intellectual Capital~An Introduction, Financial Management, 78V2W~32-36. 38. Edvinsson, L., and Malone, ., 1997. Intellectual Capital: Realizing Your Company’s Trure Value by Finding It’s Hidden Roots. New York: Harper Business. 39. Fitz-Enz, J., 1997. “Are your human assets outperforming the market?”, Management Review, 86 Feb ~62-66. 40. Fitz-Enz, J., 2000. The ROI of Human Capital~Measuring the Economic Value of Employee Performance. American Management Association. 41. Grossman, R. J., 2000. Measuring Up. HR Magazine, 45: 28-35. 25
42. Haig R. Nalbantain, R. A. G., Dave Kieffer, Jay Doherty (2004). Play to your strengths~managing your internal labor markets for lasting competitive advantage. 43. Hermanson, R. H. (1964). Accounting for Human Assets., Occasional Paper 44. Huselid, ., Jackson, ., & Schuler, ., 1997. Technical and strategic human resource management effectiveness as determinants offirm performance, Academy of Management Journal, 40(1¦~171-188. 45. Ichniowski, C., Shaw, K. and Prennushi, G., 1997. The Effects of Human Resource Management Practices and Productivity: A Study of Steel Finishing Lines, The American Economic Review, 8 291-313. 46. Knight, D. J. (1999). Performance measures for increasing intellectual capital. Strategy & Leadership, 2 ~22-27. 47. Laker, D. R., 1990. Dual dimensionality of training transfer. Human Resource Development Quarterly, 1(3 209-223. 48. Lepak & Scott A. Snell (1999). Toward a theory of human capital allocation and development. Academy of Management Review, 2 ~31-48. 49. Lockheed, M. E., Jamison, D. T. and Lau, L. J., 1980. Farmer Education and Farm Efficiency: A Survey. In Timothy King ed. Education and Income. Washington DC: The World Bank Staff Working Paper. 40 136. 50. Lynn, B. E., 2000. Intellectual capital: Unearthing hidden value by managing intellectual assets. Ivey Business journal 64(3¦~48-52. 51. Mayo, A., 2001. The Human Value of The Enterprise~Valuing People as AssetsMonitoring, Measuring, Managing, London~Nicholas Brealey Publishing. 52. Miler, ., 1990, The strategic management of technological R & D – an ideal process for the 1990’s, International Journal of Technology 26
Management, 5(2¦~63-153. 53. Mincer, J., 1974. Schooling Experience and Earnings, NY: Columbia University Press for National Bureau of Economic Research. 54. Nkomo, ., 1987. Human resource planning and organization performanc ~An exploratory analysis, Strategic Management Journal, 8 July/Aug ~387-392. 55. Schultz, T. W., 1960. Investment in human capital, Presidential address before the American Economic Association. American Economic Review, 51, March,1961. 27
