31 5 , 5 SystemsEngineering—Theory&PracticeMay,2011:1000-6788(2011)05-0792-07 :;F752 .7
:A1,
2,
3, 3(1. , 100190;2. , 100190; /#3. !" e 0
))$PQ % BCD EFB=CB)C )_G H \.`/0) 1, '2 (31X400Y519Z60)104&'()*+ , -, 789:;<=>:;<,?@8A'.4IJKLM:BCD EFNA');BCD EF RSTNBCU
VW )BC[
\MBOC)
P QO, ]STNVW^'(),Æa A'BCU
NW^'() bcd. BCD EF; fF; ./0;9:;</0;>:;</0;g h67EmpiricalstudyonexportspromotingeffectofChina’sexportcreditinsurance1233HEShen-yuan,LIBin,PANGShu-juan,WANGShou-yang(&DataScience,ChineseAcademyofSciences,Beijing100190,China;,GraduateUniversityofChineseAcademyofSciences,Beijing100190,China;,ChineseAcademyofSciences,Beijing100190,China),theempiricalresultsshowthatexportcreditinsurancesignificantlypromotesexportsofChinaandithasashort-termeffectonexportstodevelopingcountrieswhilealong-termeffectonexportstodevelopedcountrieswhichisduetotheChinesefirms’;politicalrisk;gravitymodel;staticpaneldatamodel;dynamicpaneldatamodel;generalizedmethodofmoments1ij2008 , “ ”
,
. ,
,
.: . . : ; , : !k l" # % $&"
#! . $
, "# $ ,!. ,
( Æ 10% % . & '.! : !19 19 "'#"
% , $ ; ) Æ & Æ * .:2010-05-31:( #(1973–), , ) + ,,Æ.
1
1
$ - 5 - )* .., 4 & 7 8$ 1( 1 %') %
,
! ' ( #!, -:# *
., $$ % / ! + . $0 % ' % 1 " (& & -% # , 2"[1],( ,) ) # $$3 . % , /5* +*-Æ.42002 *%+ 2009 987*%+, ' %, 2009 6() % , &,+ 24 18 .2 * %!+', , " / #.*,/ /+ 4(25)+ 98, 00) 5 30* ' * $( 1 2 3, $ 4 ..) -* 64
()+5 ,: 1 : 2 ,. $ ,3*- 7 0 .:;6<1, - /* , * 3, 7 & *9 6 7 / ;; <, /:;
) ./*0# )5,= )*0# ,0 6
<1 40;;2<1 .12 ! 65$6
,
/1 16*- o-&8/ 3 4!: 9 @ 9 > 5 /.;3<1,
* 6*1,=# = ">.2mn[2.=Fu na tsu,1 4 ]7 4 7 $ $ ,( : 1 ? ?0 8;; 6 , 83 .Abraham [3]Dewit ,1'"#
83 : 5 A , /6 863
:. / *,7/ @ )0. :1 A 9 < = - 27B% $18 D 2 ="B:7 5 8 @< : C 8,33 =<
7 ;,: 4: >5/ .;9 = ,
!
<1 B , )B 3, D;< 1Æ [4]2].Dewit(=
[Funatsu , /*
'? $ 2"
& >3 . ?*8=, #>, >A E ;# <B;7?>A C D C B 0 ? 6 4GG = 8 38 2 =- # ;F: B, ? .@@ &>A, "#
?$ )5, ,E A0 8334)@ '. 5, '; @) B5, 7 “>5” ,
>3 5 “> 5$” C B B 5 >E58 A 5 F ,: ; ,4 F <: >5 >6 , B -2 HA 6 83 >
6> , 6 ?
8 ) : @ 1, ?-? . ) 5 /* G ' @ 5 -..)5 ienstra-Munnicha [5]Turvey#
)5, )5=,
,H 6 , C 6B 1 @E I
% I
, ?I 1 -E1 /27 ,
19 3 E, # H>A: B E 327 . .1- , AB4
I
J 4 ,,
H>A,@ : 1 :
*I*
6 G
- D F 6 E
N * :GB $ 3 1 ,
0 4 , D 60K $8
3 > 5 5 D2 7 D E.& G 7 1 ?4 Æ C : 1 % #&
G ,D, [6].Egger Url4 JB 9,0,/. .1/.9: 3, H G 1K % * L3 =,
H,M. ,:/;. EH5 : ),0& 7 ?; 1-=!6 ,
Æ. 1 4
)F[7].Mah/*
) $ .
,# EAG 0 GD:GDP 8 Æ J ,
?
,Johansen Engle-GrangerG GD B=
J4 E ,@: ) % =, /*
, . $ ) [8].Moser Nestmann Wedow. /*-. Egger[6]Url /*-.@) 0,J #
4 )5,H )* +
9O. 51 :N
7 94 4 = 4J .)) N -R/FO = 6 * K *, -8 %
=M Q@ , 0 FGKPHLK"I 31 EulerHermes1 L$ ; .,=
H,A04 )5, ,1- 6 0 $ I D= /*.JÆK[9]6 [10]Rienstra-Munnicha )5, 7 . + R PM,,=)/**;* + <)
2.#=+ 5 >5 G D . )
.6, : 1 : 1L )L, ) )
; , .//> **?9) q,5@@0S)&5, 4@ )5 -. D/*
$ , ,1'/* * 3*- $ .3 : 4 )5 @S& 6 0: , 1- N+B T5@. )-
N +@,/() $ [11].4 )5' NO4 /* M,Q:
E5 ,/.4 )5 )& [12],H 23 RLM,, AndersonN?
4 )5 @S,=#
D:D B5iS7 βk B5ηkµkλkεkM=α 4j 4 +Hk,Y Y1' i j ijkij @1 E V P &? O)
, L5LN M ÆN N @ 1B ' O @ )i/ *4j G) D5 B5 # ,Dijij,
/* i j Æ @B$ 7M N H, UV? ) 5 N @,2ijk,
!E(LnU)=0, UQ , :.ijk, +
. ,)* /* ,@ 74 )5B ,= GDP MN # Æ GDQ ,N@,P
GD , D 6BU D )5@)N@ : ln(Exports)=β+βln(GDP)+βln(Distance)+βln(Pop)+βln(ECI)i,t01i,t2i3i,t4i,t +βPr+βOthers+µ+µ+ε5i,t6i,tit (1)i,t
, l+n ( E) x pKo rPtÆsQC)Q Æ
O #T 3Gi XD 2 B 5 BG5Dt* 6 Æ ,,ln(GDP)i B5t*i,ti,tGDP ,,W C B5
+,ln(Distance) i B5MN i,ÆC: D )B ,,W ,ln(Pop) it*# , ,,W C B5
L,ln(ECI)i,ti,ti B5t* Æ(exportcreditinsurance) ,,Pr i,t,Othersi,t, /*>
2P () .H)M5 6
. BOTG: 3 7 E7 /. Q, Z0 -:G? , *RI:Q
Æ,0 )@?G .@F@GsH104 B5 .),0 GD B5B' 2002–2009 ,.104 .) B5 CEIC,0P.(GDP) .
+ KPQQÆ )@ 6 Y@ 1Æ; :V, .
+ KPQQÆ ). 5)5 GDÆC -G B* I H M O TGD' .-, + 9,0)5,@( W 4# ÆÆ3 F X )2E A ,Æ 0, [0 D ÆO),L@0 ' % + ) Æ -E% Æ # , M N
+ ) & #
+, 9,0") ,*K , 2,Q: ,4 ..GDP, 4 %+ )Æ E 5F , E4: 9O B2 @?.104 B5 # ,0 )@ 6 Y@ 1Æ, E \R#.
N1 G5M5 *W D BN +T
# _ PR S , S 1 9S M ,^ )N
D ,8 S 02 I R V . W( A WJ# ,- : 7 *.$$%/!+.$0%'%1"(&&795 1604Y 1 B5(AJ) B MN, E -=.4 )5, ") ]^ GD, MQ ,.:M.,)*:Q
InternationalCountryRiskGui, 4 1-U de (RY Æ9IC,RG9,) ,ICRG9,
"T- TX,C9,4., #3 X2 , : E )
9,,: )&5,1–100,1,)
,C ) & T,R Ca 0W @) O)Q < @I3V
#
,
P #3X2 ,)5#
104 %+#3 X2(% #3@U@J ;+),Q: Z#3G2U. `I \1@., C9,VV [#3X2 ,
[#3G2 7 ., ÆRSXtTu Ue\Tf%UZExports(.$X)g[]+Y(ln)GDP(*^_hVT)`W]+Y(ln)Pop( $)g[ +Y(ln)Distance(YZ)Y[+Y(ln)ECI(.$$%/!X)a]+Y(ln)Pr(WX) @ 5 #4 ) 3 53Z*! Y Y*)- \ 83 2$ \Y\Ersta([bi\)%832−0.,60
))C55 , BS@ :M N G5D1 _`abAra/W+ 9) 5BK @G)G\N=T@,Z0 2]+) ^S7 : ,;/ S/+17 N+ .,1'0 @ 69 2) +5 9 ] )9+T 5)*5(A$ bs)4Z v
[P\ ]^w 0 4 (1)@ 6]).AB])
A PC ,S B^ ,C 4 N3^])(1) 62+ 9)5]), _Y 9,0 ,=6,@ ])(1),2P])j1k\/yT z` (hi)\Tcaaaln(GDP)(Pop)−(WDistance)−−−*(ECI)(Ersta)−−−(Constant)
B. )]) le)3f5a ` abf[^:a,b,c jkl[,]d^_m,^`.\]ec,a`1dm^_[,nb[l2 : 0 4 ) 5 ÆR T.-,d,:Q GD 5BLM Æ.4ln(ECI) , ,!.- 2,d, 3*-,
7 W9 6 H F ) %B$5
+ T . - FGKPHLK"I 31 . ,)5 Pr ,.- 2,d,> B5 PrI)
,Q )L, C B5 ) , D 6 ,=! UC ,)
& 2 ,
)U
;ln(GD, ' P) ln(Pop),d, B5
+)& ))
, ;Abs(Ersta)W > B5#3X2@3 I, 0 7A: B8C. 2 )C C B 5B 5 B bH5 0 . - #3X2 -, 5/'= . - B5 # 3,- TSf,dg, , ,0(eW #13 X 2&A
#0 . .)1' 6,d, & # C, D,=S 9 ,,: )56 )5 , 3 ..,)56 & ln(Pop) , S,
!, =_,)5 0 ln(Pop) =^.-, 4 d0 Fh U
p #
d,EhD8 &1 .%U= L : : 0 hij , U & 74 & @ G =?
E 8 . & , c f4 TE84dh
,
4,
4 6h U$; & g: TE8,H @UC, & , - B * D, # .,)56 D , 2,! .-,d, / ,^: &
<1 UL . , )5 =@,)5 0 B #@ 3 E =D @ ,X 42
@ &,d3q 2,
j= ) @ i & & 8 2^ *, E# 3 X 2 = 0F I. =- : ik?4&,
@ & , = I i74h G H A , 0 8L, H .(Abs(Ersta)) )5 , ) 5 6 && . ) ])1,CGD= .-,,
& , 2 0 Q L & 4 i 0 ,
># , (U 3. )
@ C X <) 1 25 4 6Æ H ,A & Ue&n
,! * -& 0
E Æ 70%,
"# * jf82 B & + % $) ; H
, @ B , F 3*-82 , :4 (
# ,#3 3*X.(ln( EC I )) , , )5 '.- 2,H )5 0 , ]1d,
.) CGD:3, A)`o=k,,F l ./*1/=,
: [8] .. )+ .2 .9 p)
`5/am*b A@*r -P q $ ,4 N3^])(GMM)])2+ 9)5,2,; U2 .)[13],)*#Q .) 104 B5,r 8 B, Tm@# 2+ 9)5 6]).2+ L4A MB LM # *- q
) 9())5 7 ]G)DC )7 I + )GD,. +7 * Æ , (1)G :ln(Exports)=β+βln(Exports)+βln(GDP)+βln(Di,t01i,t−12i,t35istance)+βln(Pop)i4i,t+βln(ECI)+βPr+βOthers+µ+µ+ε(2)5i,t6i,t7i,titi,t(2) 2+ 9)5, ])C)5 4 GMM 5F: ,G D. ) B GE<DP -#G3? 1G D 8 :8 i ,2 n7 / ,4 GMM 5 F ; p, H^ , E <[ GD LMGD ,GMM4 L1 ,Bkl 3= 5fjGD ().GMM]) GMM]),B@ 8]) OJLE 7 kg, ?0 8GMM])D lom 1 n,0 / * 4 8GMM])D. , GMM
, KHA @L1GMM4 ,,@ :
8 GMM ,
G?@: ,D 5 0 ,]L ]]] )M ))) G#122]( #,-: *.$$%/!+.$0%'%1"(&&797,1D/++)Q/= 99 D ) ]5 h)3 , = h ? 2 G2?D G0 .D]6 )GO D T, G kD[14][15].Arellano Bover Blundell Bond# lm(Sargan)L1G , H>A h 2GD , , / H>A.,? 2n; =b? (),Q:> B$-
<[ , , @jU23n ;B =2b+ (9))5 , +
d, 4 i ..3 :;
7 * Æ LMGD *7 I 2GD=4 8 GMM]) .)52 4
.),0]) 1/,)53 )5m 1' & 0 .B 3 3 ,0 *7 Æ(ln(Exports(−1)))'.- 2,d,2+
G>Æ) DA 57 H > ,,A 2 1@* - = 1 . E EP o ? 6 ? m O = G n.- q
)n
, 9,: k.
rl: *- .lm(Sargan)G D I 10% e ' .-,d, /:Q % e ' .-, E mO= H,.,)5 A , ,GMM])j2
mO= ?. *-Z
GDP ,# MN #3X2' , F 6 e n , H Mo ?4 L M : , *- .aWK3s\dTepfgxtSu\vTq\Toaaaln(Exports(−1))(GDP)(Pop)(Distance)−−(ECI)(Ersta)−−(Constant)−−*(c1_)(2) ddpB@,7)4 5 * 2 - ) 5 B m 5Æ 4@ q 70 @ q7 7 ;&
&q .)'1 0s4 ? 7. - 22Æ9 l 75:\]ec, popaW1efdgga[3 7,., ?7 Æ ,,d, 1
@ 0 ,. B@ & 07 0 , %$
4 & * @ !&3,=, & 42 bp?.(ln(ECI)) , 3 , &, b p ? 7 & $ , 0 .14
@r1 q1
@ 07 0 0 .0 4,. 1/3o /+)5 1 0 r,H 6&, = ,7 & ,B, *- r ; 0 ,=@ &, bp= UL, # 3* ( 3 2,@ 2 + )) )*5 & t s 7 y
| & 3;: : 1/.5[w]{x10 4 2 .B-5 $ 6
1-, 4 )5 -. "#
/+ ,/*
$ ,6 .) 6u,
, ] )v,q: 1 :AB, ; p T , 3*- 7 0 2 4,.
71$ 9 8 , .; $ FGKPHL>K"Iit= B@ & bp ?i31 , *- 7 & % 4
, .)* /* 0# ":, S]1 r $ s .g: 0 r%
-d,H s2 “ ” , U B-JS r tF . L.-$ ,; % s"v# 4 ÆX, F 6 WTO r $.
$, * 4 u I &,, 6h w
Gs, , X
zt UC, ,? hs ,J
U& . W 10–20 4
5 . ; h es & ,Æ 7 $ EG,d rtF.;6, tFR “ += '”. L.-$ 0, @ " += {Qt ',x^w ,
. ? 2, S hs U& #>
$, |=} } x~L : Etu Æv w 4 x ' ( 78 [3 ,u &$ &H 7 ['
' : vB '5 . 'D # ., -%S^5 QvH : 5 './* ,, , FHdU, 2 U& ik.,& ' u . ,. %S : e 61 , . &F [ : ',.[1]ww,%.$$%/!_+yzyz+ *.$yv1wx[J].*yzyz{,2008(10):106–,-primemortgagecrisestoChina’sexportsenterprisesthroughexportcreditinsurance[J].InternationalTradeJournal,2008(10):106–122.[2][J].JournalofRiskandInsurance,1986(6):79–92.[3]AbrahamF,[J].OpenEconomiesReview,2000,11(1):5–26.[4]:Insurance,strategicactionoraid?[J].EuropeanJournalofPoliticalEconomy,2001,17(3):575–592.[5]Rienstra-MunnichaP,,creditriskandcreditguarantees[J].CanadianJournalofAgriculturalEconomics,2002,50(3):281–296.[6]EggerP,:EvidencefromAustria[J].WorldEconomy,2006,29(4):399–418.[7]:TheexperienceofJapan[J].JournalofAsianEconomics,2006,17(4):646–652.[8]MoserC,NestmannT,:EvidencefromGermany[J].WorldEconomy,2008,31(6):781–803.[9]zz{,|{|.$%Z!{.$$%/!b.$zy{F1&&[J].|a&&,2010,36(5):113–,,exportscreditinsuranceandexportstrade[J].JournalofFinanceandEconomics,2010,36(5):113–122.[10][D].2003.[11]}}{,|}|,}}).~|\T[*yzy _%1HL~~&&~~[J].~}a~&&,2005(2):39–,GuHY,[J].NankaiEconomicStudies,2005(2):39–44.[12][J].TheAmericanEconomicReview,1979,69(1):106–116.[13]:Anintroductionto“difference”and“system”GMMinStata[R].CenterforGlobalDevelopmentWorkingPaper,2006.[14]ArellanoM,[J].JournalofEconometrics,1995,68:29–51.[15]BlundellR,[J].JournalofEconometrics,1998,87:115–143.
